Publish: 11:25, 10 Sep, 2024

New constitution or amendments

Golam Rabbani & Arafat Munna
New constitution or amendments
সংগৃহীত ছবি

Following the ouster of the Awami League government amid a student-led movement, discussions are underway regarding the possible restructuring of Bangladesh’s political and constitutional framework.

Public discourse has intensified, with many suggesting that Bangladesh’s return to stability will hinge on constitutional changes. While some have advocated for comprehensive amendments, others have called for a complete rewrite of the constitution. The interim government, led by Prof. Muhammad Yunus, has not yet reached a conclusion on the matter, but discussions are actively taking place.

AF Hasan Arif, Adviser to the Ministry of Local Government, Rural Development, and Cooperatives, confirmed that deliberations on constitutional amendments are in progress. "The opinions of the students, who spearheaded the recent movement, will be central in shaping the direction of the constitutional reforms," he stated. He also acknowledged that other major issues, including the potential reinstatement of the caretaker government system, are being discussed.

Arif emphasized the importance of student input in determining whether the existing constitution should be reformed or replaced entirely. "The demand must come from the students. Whether they desire an entirely new framework or just reforms to the current constitution will guide the decisions made by the government," he said.

The question of constitutional reform is being tied to broader discussions about the future of elections in the country, with the caretaker government system—abolished in 2011—being a key topic of debate. The adviser confirmed that any decision about constitutional amendments or the election system would be made based on recommendations from relevant stakeholders, including students and political leaders.

While talking to Bangladesh Pratidin, ZI Khan Panna, a senior lawyer at the Supreme Court, argued that reforms are essential for moving the country forward. "The current constitution, written in 1971, was created in a very different context. It is now being used to maintain the power of the ruling elite," Panna told Bangladesh Pratidin. He called for the inclusion of minority rights, particularly for indigenous groups, in any future amendments. "The rights of all people must be guaranteed. Without such changes, how can we claim to have a functioning democracy?" he questioned.

Panna also warned against completely discarding the constitution, suggesting that a full repeal could lead to instability and the need for further constitutional changes in the near future. "If we abolish the constitution entirely, we could be rewriting it again in ten to twenty years," he cautioned.

Badiul Alam Majumdar, Secretary of civil society organization Sujan (Citizens for Good Governance), told Bangladesh Pratidin that while radical changes are needed, the process of writing a new constitution would be arduous and time-consuming.

"Rewriting the constitution from scratch is not easy, and it will take a long time," Majumdar said. "However, significant reforms can still be made to the existing constitution." He cited several areas in need of change, including the balance of power between the president and the prime minister, and Article 70, which restricts members of parliament from voting against their party.

Majumdar also highlighted the caretaker government issue, calling it a "political compromise" that was abolished after the Awami League’s 15th amendment. Both the Awami League and the BNP, he argued, are responsible for the system’s demise, and the issue must be addressed in any future reforms.

Several legal experts have pointed out specific amendments in need of repeal, particularly Article 7(a), which was introduced by the 15th amendment. Majumdar warned that this provision, which could lead to charges of treason against those advocating for constitutional change, would endanger the very figures pushing for reforms. "If Article 7(a) is not repealed, even the current interim government could face charges of treason for discussing changes to the constitution," he noted.

Barrister Sara Hossain, another senior Supreme Court lawyer, echoed the need for significant reforms. "The existing constitution contains elements that are incompatible with a modern democratic state," she said, citing the death penalty as one such issue. "A new Bangladesh would need to abolish the death penalty, ensure freedom of expression, and guarantee fundamental rights for all citizens. Any amendments should reflect the full spectrum of Bangladesh’s people, not just the ruling elites."

(The report was published on print and online versions of The Bangladesh Pratidin on September 10 and rewritten in English by Tanvir Raihan)

More News
Great opportunities as Eastern Europe seeks foreign workers
Great opportunities as Eastern Europe seeks foreign workers
Banned polythene endangers environment
Banned polythene endangers environment
Foreign banks reluctant to issue LCs for some banks in the country
Foreign banks reluctant to issue LCs for some banks in the country
FBCCI involved in implementing govt’s agenda
FBCCI involved in implementing govt’s agenda
Hundi becomes reckless using TallyPay
Hundi becomes reckless using TallyPay
Big statistical discrepancies to show fake development in AL regime
Big statistical discrepancies to show fake development in AL regime
Majumdar's associates target Jamuna Bank takeover
Majumdar's associates target Jamuna Bank takeover
October dengue surge: 38 Deaths and 40,000+ hospitalizations
October dengue surge: 38 Deaths and 40,000+ hospitalizations
Export of Tk 2,500 crore charcoal in uncertainty
Export of Tk 2,500 crore charcoal in uncertainty
Govt earns billions of taka from unemployment
Govt earns billions of taka from unemployment
Excessive presence of heavy metal in Sitakunda wounds’ blood
Excessive presence of heavy metal in Sitakunda wounds’ blood
ACC, CID begin probe against Meghna Group over money laundering
ACC, CID begin probe against Meghna Group over money laundering
Latest News
Ex-DNCC Mayor Atiq arrested
Ex-DNCC Mayor Atiq arrested

3 hours ago | National

Govt plans to introduce pension for RMG workers: Asif
Govt plans to introduce pension for RMG workers: Asif

3 hours ago | National

Great opportunities as Eastern Europe seeks foreign workers
Great opportunities as Eastern Europe seeks foreign workers

3 hours ago | Special

‘Interim Govt doesn’t acknowledge Sheikh Mujib as Father of the Nation’: Nahid
‘Interim Govt doesn’t acknowledge Sheikh Mujib as Father of the Nation’: Nahid

4 hours ago | National

Bashundhara Shuvosangho distributes food among underprivileged people
Bashundhara Shuvosangho distributes food among underprivileged people

4 hours ago | Shuvosangho

World Food Day: Speakers for reducing waste to ensure food security
World Food Day: Speakers for reducing waste to ensure food security

5 hours ago | National

CA visits graffitis drawn by young revolutionaries at DU
CA visits graffitis drawn by young revolutionaries at DU

6 hours ago | National

Bangladesh Navy detains 31 Indian fishermen for illegal fishing
Bangladesh Navy detains 31 Indian fishermen for illegal fishing

6 hours ago | National

Shakib in Bangladesh squad for his last Test
Shakib in Bangladesh squad for his last Test

6 hours ago | Sports

Police to get new uniform, logo soon
Police to get new uniform, logo soon

7 hours ago | National

Dhaka voices “deep concern” over recent influx of 40,000 Rohingyas
Dhaka voices “deep concern” over recent influx of 40,000 Rohingyas

7 hours ago | National

Malaysia's 99-year-old ex-PM Mahathir in hospital again
Malaysia's 99-year-old ex-PM Mahathir in hospital again

8 hours ago | International

CA for enhanced trade cooperation between Bangladesh and Bhutan
CA for enhanced trade cooperation between Bangladesh and Bhutan

8 hours ago | National

Travel ban imposed on ex-MPs Showkat, Azad, Shaheen Chaklader
Travel ban imposed on ex-MPs Showkat, Azad, Shaheen Chaklader

8 hours ago | National

Indian airlines receive hoax bomb threats
Indian airlines receive hoax bomb threats

9 hours ago | International

12 High Court Judges being sent on leave
12 High Court Judges being sent on leave

9 hours ago | National

Conflict in Congo raises mental health issues
Conflict in Congo raises mental health issues

9 hours ago | International

‘Significant results won’t be seen soon regardless of fiscal policy’
‘Significant results won’t be seen soon regardless of fiscal policy’

9 hours ago | Economy

Body of BNP leader Harris Chowdhury exhumed
Body of BNP leader Harris Chowdhury exhumed

9 hours ago | National

Fuel tanker explosion in Nigeria killed 90
Fuel tanker explosion in Nigeria killed 90

9 hours ago | International

UK inflation hits three-year low, fuelling rate-cut hopes
UK inflation hits three-year low, fuelling rate-cut hopes

9 hours ago | International

Judges appointed during AL govt on leave: Sources
Judges appointed during AL govt on leave: Sources

9 hours ago | National

32,733 accidents in Bangladesh result in 35,384 deaths since 2019
32,733 accidents in Bangladesh result in 35,384 deaths since 2019

9 hours ago | National

Harris would ‘cut her own path’: Biden
Harris would ‘cut her own path’: Biden

10 hours ago | International

Case filed over 2014 attack on Khaleda Zia's rally stage
Case filed over 2014 attack on Khaleda Zia's rally stage

10 hours ago | National

Matia Chowdhury passes away
Matia Chowdhury passes away

10 hours ago | National

155 acres of occupied BFIDC land recovered
155 acres of occupied BFIDC land recovered

10 hours ago | National

Tigers’ new coach Phil Simmons arrives in Dhaka
Tigers’ new coach Phil Simmons arrives in Dhaka

10 hours ago | Sports

ICT prosecution to follow due process in trying journalists
ICT prosecution to follow due process in trying journalists

10 hours ago | National

Normalcy returns to RMG sector
Normalcy returns to RMG sector

11 hours ago | National

Most Read
Flood victims in remote areas get food aid
Flood victims in remote areas get food aid

1 month ago | National

Bashundhara Group urges govt to stop propaganda to safeguard millions’ livelihoods
Bashundhara Group urges govt to stop propaganda to safeguard millions’ livelihoods

1 week ago | National

Nowfel and Liton: Duo in looting Tk 5,000 crore through fake cigarettes, band rolls
Nowfel and Liton: Duo in looting Tk 5,000 crore through fake cigarettes, band rolls

1 week ago | Special

Agarwala’s Diamond World evades Tk25,200cr in VAT
Agarwala’s Diamond World evades Tk25,200cr in VAT

1 month ago | National

What's behind China's gold-buying spree?
What's behind China's gold-buying spree?

6 months ago | Feature

Tasty drinks to boost kids' immunity in winter
Tasty drinks to boost kids' immunity in winter

9 months ago | Lifestyle

Prince Harry, Britney Spears’ memoirs shortlisted for British Book Awards
Prince Harry, Britney Spears’ memoirs shortlisted for British Book Awards

7 months ago | Lifestyle

Pori Moni’s film campaign in Kolkata’s puja mandap
Pori Moni’s film campaign in Kolkata’s puja mandap

2 days ago | Showbiz

Russell's Viper: Myths, Facts, and Everything You Need to Know
Russell's Viper: Myths, Facts, and Everything You Need to Know

3 months ago | Feature

Who was Thomas Matthew Crooks, the 20-year-old man tagged as Trump Shooter
Who was Thomas Matthew Crooks, the 20-year-old man tagged as Trump Shooter

3 months ago | International

English Speaking Clubs in Bangladeshi Schools: A Path to Global Competence
English Speaking Clubs in Bangladeshi Schools: A Path to Global Competence

7 months ago | Reader column

Concerns mount over looted weapons
Concerns mount over looted weapons

2 months ago | Special

Pakistan takes on Sri Lanka in Asia Cup final
Pakistan takes on Sri Lanka in Asia Cup final

2 years ago | Sports

Bangladesh to play two T20s against UAE
Bangladesh to play two T20s against UAE

2 years ago | Sports

Woman held with 20 gold bars in Chuadanga
Woman held with 20 gold bars in Chuadanga

1 year ago | National

World's rarest whale washes up on New Zealand beach
World's rarest whale washes up on New Zealand beach

3 months ago | Feature

Facebook turns 20: From Zuckerberg's dormitory to a $1tn company
Facebook turns 20: From Zuckerberg's dormitory to a $1tn company

8 months ago | Feature

Newly appointed Indian HC Pranay Kumar arrives in Dhaka
Newly appointed Indian HC Pranay Kumar arrives in Dhaka

2 years ago | National

Some skills to learn before going to study abroad
Some skills to learn before going to study abroad

9 months ago | Lifestyle

Factors that influence ADHD symptoms
Factors that influence ADHD symptoms

3 months ago | Lifestyle

Coconut for summer skin and hair care
Coconut for summer skin and hair care

3 months ago | Lifestyle

Study reveals changing attitudes of Bangladeshis towards Rohingya refugees
Study reveals changing attitudes of Bangladeshis towards Rohingya refugees

5 months ago | Feature

Sajia Tonny's 'Style with Me by Sajia' becomes popular in social media
Sajia Tonny's 'Style with Me by Sajia' becomes popular in social media

4 months ago | Lifestyle

Exploring Ratargul Swamp Forest: A Comprehensive Travel Guide to the “Amazon of Bangladesh”
Exploring Ratargul Swamp Forest: A Comprehensive Travel Guide to the “Amazon of Bangladesh”

5 months ago | Feature

Pentagon ran secret anti-vax campaign to undermine China during pandemic
Pentagon ran secret anti-vax campaign to undermine China during pandemic

4 months ago | Feature

King Charles III celebrates 75th birthday
King Charles III celebrates 75th birthday

11 months ago | Lifestyle

Dhakaiaa Jamdani revolutionizing fashion in Bangladesh
Dhakaiaa Jamdani revolutionizing fashion in Bangladesh

3 months ago | Lifestyle

Aquaculture production overtakes capture fisheries for first time
Aquaculture production overtakes capture fisheries for first time

4 months ago | Feature

Real Madrid down Juventus 2-0 in friendly
Real Madrid down Juventus 2-0 in friendly

2 years ago | Sports

Girl discovers dinosaur footprints on beach
Girl discovers dinosaur footprints on beach

1 month ago | Lifestyle