Publish: 19:21, 31 Jan, 2025 Updated: 19:23, 31 Jan, 2025

HRW Report

Political leadership ordered excessive use of force during July Uprising: HRW

Online Desk
Political leadership ordered excessive use of force during July Uprising: HRW
Photo: BSS

The political leadership ordered the excessive use of police force during the July Uprising, the Human Rights Watch (HRW), one of the world's most respected human rights group, said in a report released on January 27.

"Multiple police officers indicated that they believed that directives to use excessive force during the Uprising came from political leadership," the report said.

A HRW delegation, led by Elaine Pearson, Asia Director, on January 28, handed over the 50-page report titled "After the Monsoon Revolution A Roadmap to Lasting Security Sector Reform in Bangladesh" to Chief Adviser Prof Muhammad Yunus.

In an interview to HRW, a police officer said, "I believe that during the unrest, the role of the police was determined more by political leaders than by the officers in the field."

One police officer told Human Rights Watch, "The police also shot at onlookers observing the scene from their homes, intending to create fear and send a message that people should not watch what was happening around them." 

Police officers described receiving both explicit and implicit orders throughout the protests to use lethal force, the report said.

One officer explained, "Senior officers ordered us to be strict and not to spare any criminals spreading anarchy." 

They didn't explicitly use the word "fire," but their instructions were clear: Apply the highest force, do whatever you think is necessary to control the situation, take a hardline approach, the report said.

The same officer also described witnessing more explicit directions. 

He said that senior officers from Dhaka Metropolitan Police Headquarters would watch live CCTV footage and direct officers on the ground to shoot like "they were ordering someone to shoot in a video game."

He said that as he understood it, the home minister, Asaduzzaman Khan, and the inspector general of police, Chowdhury Abdullah Al-Mamun, gave directions to the Dhaka metropolitan police commissioner, Habibur Rahman, who instructed the deputy commissioners. 

This hierarchy of command is consistent with Bangladesh's police structure and reporting lines leading up to the home minister, the HRW report said.

A video in August showed a police officer in Dhaka defending police actions and telling Khan about the protesters' persistence: "We shoot one dead, or we wound one, and that is the only one that falls. The rest don't budge, sir."

On July 26, 2024, six coordinators of the student movement were abducted by plain clothes police after they went to a hospital in Dhaka to treat injuries sustained because of excessive force by police or attacks from Awami League supporters, the report said.

The six were held in incommunicado detention for a week and were "reportedly forced to issue a video statement announcing the end of the protest movement" before they were released on August 1, it said.

On August 5, Sheikh Hasina resigned and fled the country.

In some cases, police also fuelled the post-August 5 chaos and violence, according to the HRW. 

"For instance, on August 5, in Ashulia, police set fire to vehicles carrying dead and injured protesters. At least one person, according to an eyewitness, was burned alive in handcuffs," it said.

Razia Begum(55), who witnessed the events said, "This was the first time in my life that I saw innocent people burned alive this way."

She said that when neighbors saw the flames they ran to put out the fire but police turned on them and began shooting. 

"The roads were covered with blood," said Razia.

"People were fatally shot directly in their bodies, not in their legs," he said.

BSS

Bd-Pratidin English/ARK

More News
Rajshahi division gets 2,36,997 new voters
Rajshahi division gets 2,36,997 new voters
Bangladesh housing sector in crisis, facing severe stagnation
Bangladesh housing sector in crisis, facing severe stagnation
Magura rape victim shifted to paediatric ICU at CMH
Magura rape victim shifted to paediatric ICU at CMH
First batch of medical tourists to leave for China today
First batch of medical tourists to leave for China today
Home adviser inspects four police stations early Monday
Home adviser inspects four police stations early Monday
Enhancing jute use essential for sustainable development: Rizwana
Enhancing jute use essential for sustainable development: Rizwana
What future leaders can learn from Prof Yunus
What future leaders can learn from Prof Yunus
‘Govt adopts zero tolerance policy against anarchies’
‘Govt adopts zero tolerance policy against anarchies’
‘Will make such policy that no one can shut down internet’
‘Will make such policy that no one can shut down internet’
Zero tolerance for rape: Home Adviser
Zero tolerance for rape: Home Adviser
BNP announces new date for Iftar Mahfil with political parties
BNP announces new date for Iftar Mahfil with political parties
Court orders freezing ex-minister Saifuzzaman’s assets
Court orders freezing ex-minister Saifuzzaman’s assets
Latest News
Nissan tests driverless cars on busy Japan city streets
Nissan tests driverless cars on busy Japan city streets
just now | Tech
Inzamam tells Gavaskar to control his tongue
Inzamam tells Gavaskar to control his tongue
4 minutes ago | Sports
Tokyo was filled with charred corpses after US firebombing 80 years ago. Survivors want compensation
Tokyo was filled with charred corpses after US firebombing 80 years ago. Survivors want compensation
9 minutes ago | International
Thai man arrested for laundering money for call centre scam gangs
Thai man arrested for laundering money for call centre scam gangs
19 minutes ago | Tech
Scholars stranded worldwide due to US State Dept funding freeze
Scholars stranded worldwide due to US State Dept funding freeze
28 minutes ago | International
Rajshahi division gets 2,36,997 new voters
Rajshahi division gets 2,36,997 new voters
28 minutes ago | National
Iran open to talks on nuclear militarization concerns
Iran open to talks on nuclear militarization concerns
42 minutes ago | International
Zelensky took billions from Biden like ‘candy from a baby’
Zelensky took billions from Biden like ‘candy from a baby’
45 minutes ago | International
Malaysia has to sign at least eight protocols to use nuclear energy, says minister
Malaysia has to sign at least eight protocols to use nuclear energy, says minister
48 minutes ago | International
Dizziness could signal anaemia: Causes, symptoms, and treatment
Dizziness could signal anaemia: Causes, symptoms, and treatment
56 minutes ago | Lifestyle
Bangladesh housing sector in crisis, facing severe stagnation
Bangladesh housing sector in crisis, facing severe stagnation
1 hour ago | National
Australia’s first 3D-printed multi-storey house under construction in Wyndham
Australia’s first 3D-printed multi-storey house under construction in Wyndham
1 hour ago | Tech
Controversy over CT final presentation ceremony
Controversy over CT final presentation ceremony
1 hour ago | Sports
More 42 metric tons of potatoes exported to Nepal thru Banglabandha port
More 42 metric tons of potatoes exported to Nepal thru Banglabandha port
1 hour ago | Business
Remittance inflows soar in early March with $814mn in 8 days
Remittance inflows soar in early March with $814mn in 8 days
1 hour ago | Business
Trump criticizes King Charles III's meeting with Zelensky, claims it damaged relations
Trump criticizes King Charles III's meeting with Zelensky, claims it damaged relations
2 hours ago | International
Sleep better, stabilise blood sugar
Sleep better, stabilise blood sugar
2 hours ago | Lifestyle
US condemns escalating violence in Syria, calls for accountability
US condemns escalating violence in Syria, calls for accountability
3 hours ago | International
RMG workers block Banani road over colleague’s death in road crash
RMG workers block Banani road over colleague’s death in road crash
3 hours ago | City
Magura rape victim shifted to paediatric ICU at CMH
Magura rape victim shifted to paediatric ICU at CMH
3 hours ago | National
Khushi Kapoor in Mom Sequel following in Sridevi's footsteps
Khushi Kapoor in Mom Sequel following in Sridevi's footsteps
3 hours ago | Entertainment
Starlink is ‘backbone’ of Ukrainian military – Musk
Starlink is ‘backbone’ of Ukrainian military – Musk
3 hours ago | Tech
Magura rape case: Main accused Hitu Sheikh on seven-day remand
Magura rape case: Main accused Hitu Sheikh on seven-day remand
3 hours ago | City
Rohit says 'not retiring' from ODIs
Rohit says 'not retiring' from ODIs
4 hours ago | Sports
How to create realistic to-do lists and avoid burnout
How to create realistic to-do lists and avoid burnout
4 hours ago | Lifestyle
First batch of medical tourists to leave for China today
First batch of medical tourists to leave for China today
4 hours ago | National
Home adviser inspects four police stations early Monday
Home adviser inspects four police stations early Monday
4 hours ago | National
Dhaka sees slight rise in temperature, dry conditions persist
Dhaka sees slight rise in temperature, dry conditions persist
4 hours ago | City
Israel cuts Gaza's electricity after halting all goods supplies
Israel cuts Gaza's electricity after halting all goods supplies
5 hours ago | International
Banker to Canada’s new prime minister: Mark Carney's unlikely rise
Banker to Canada’s new prime minister: Mark Carney's unlikely rise
5 hours ago | International
Most Read
HC orders completion of Magura child rape trial within six months
HC orders completion of Magura child rape trial within six months
23 hours ago | National
EC to issue notification on new parties’ registration Monday
EC to issue notification on new parties’ registration Monday
18 hours ago | National
Bangladesh, Kuwait commit to boost trade, energy and investment ties
Bangladesh, Kuwait commit to boost trade, energy and investment ties
23 hours ago | National
Cyclone, Kalboishakhi, and heatwaves expected from March to May
Cyclone, Kalboishakhi, and heatwaves expected from March to May
23 hours ago | National
First batch of medical tourists to leave for China today
First batch of medical tourists to leave for China today
4 hours ago | National
Take control of your life by setting powerful discipline goals
Take control of your life by setting powerful discipline goals
22 hours ago | Lifestyle
What future leaders can learn from Prof Yunus
What future leaders can learn from Prof Yunus
6 hours ago | National
Ways to reverse fatty liver
Ways to reverse fatty liver
23 hours ago | Lifestyle
RMG workers block Banani road over colleague’s death in road crash
RMG workers block Banani road over colleague’s death in road crash
3 hours ago | City
How to detect Fatty liver disease without symptoms
How to detect Fatty liver disease without symptoms
23 hours ago | Lifestyle
‘Rape probes to be completed in 15 days, trial in 90 days’
‘Rape probes to be completed in 15 days, trial in 90 days’
21 hours ago | National
Home adviser inspects four police stations early Monday
Home adviser inspects four police stations early Monday
4 hours ago | National
Bangladesh ranks first in Asia for child marriages
Bangladesh ranks first in Asia for child marriages
23 hours ago | National
Enhancing jute use essential for sustainable development: Rizwana
Enhancing jute use essential for sustainable development: Rizwana
6 hours ago | National
Mila makes her comeback to playback singing after 7 years
Mila makes her comeback to playback singing after 7 years
6 hours ago | Entertainment
Khushi Kapoor in Mom Sequel following in Sridevi's footsteps
Khushi Kapoor in Mom Sequel following in Sridevi's footsteps
3 hours ago | Entertainment
Sleep better, stabilise blood sugar
Sleep better, stabilise blood sugar
2 hours ago | Lifestyle
How to create realistic to-do lists and avoid burnout
How to create realistic to-do lists and avoid burnout
4 hours ago | Lifestyle
Dhaka chokes: World's most polluted city this morning
Dhaka chokes: World's most polluted city this morning
5 hours ago | City
Rohit says 'not retiring' from ODIs
Rohit says 'not retiring' from ODIs
4 hours ago | Sports
Bangladesh housing sector in crisis, facing severe stagnation
Bangladesh housing sector in crisis, facing severe stagnation
1 hour ago | National
Remittance inflows soar in early March with $814mn in 8 days
Remittance inflows soar in early March with $814mn in 8 days
2 hours ago | Business
‘Only an elected government can drive real economic growth’
‘Only an elected government can drive real economic growth’
21 hours ago | National
Govt to launch hotline to combat sexual harassment
Govt to launch hotline to combat sexual harassment
20 hours ago | National
Govt employees to receive salary before month ends on the occasion of Eid
Govt employees to receive salary before month ends on the occasion of Eid
21 hours ago | National
Trump administration ends Iraq's waiver to buy Iranian electricity
Trump administration ends Iraq's waiver to buy Iranian electricity
21 hours ago | International
NBR launches customs risk management to address money laundering
NBR launches customs risk management to address money laundering
20 hours ago | Business
Court orders freezing ex-minister Saifuzzaman’s assets
Court orders freezing ex-minister Saifuzzaman’s assets
18 hours ago | National
‘Govt adopts zero tolerance policy against anarchies’
‘Govt adopts zero tolerance policy against anarchies’
16 hours ago | National
China to use AI in elder care as population ages: official
China to use AI in elder care as population ages: official
22 hours ago | Tech