Publish: 08:44, 02 Jan, 2025 Updated: 10:30, 02 Jan, 2025

The endgame in Ukraine

Online Desk
The endgame in Ukraine
Photo - Collected

"I must say that the situation is changing dramatically," Russia's president, Vladimir Putin, declared at his end-of-year news conference in December.

"There is movement along the entire front line. Every day," he said.

In eastern Ukraine, Moscow's war machine is gradually churning mile by mile through the wide open fields of the Donbas, enveloping and overwhelming villages and towns, reports BBC.

Russia is gaining ground more quickly than at any time since it launched its full-scale invasion in February 2022, despite Kyiv's impressive record of well-publicised asymmetric attacks against its powerful neighbour.

As the invasion reaches the end of its third year, at an estimated cost of a million people, killed or wounded, Ukraine appears to be losing.

In distant Washington, meanwhile, the unpredictable Donald Trump, not famous for his love of Ukraine or its leader, is about to take over in the White House.

It feels like an inflection point. But could 2025 really be the year when this devastating European conflict finally comes to a close - and if so what could the endgame look like?

'Talk of negotiations is an illusion'

Trump offered some clues during recent interviews about how he intends to approach the war.

He told Time Magazine he disagreed "vehemently" with the Biden administration's decision, in November, to allow Ukraine to fire US-supplied long-range missiles at targets inside Russia.

On December 8, he was asked by NBC News if Ukraine should prepare for less aid.

"Possibly," he replied. "Probably, sure."

But to those who fear, as many do, that America's new leader is inclined to walk away from Ukraine, he offered hints of reassurance. "You can't reach an agreement if you abandon, in my opinion," he has said.

The truth is: Trump's intentions are far from clear.

And for now, Ukrainian officials reject all talk of pressure, or the suggestion that Trump's arrival necessarily means peace talks are imminent.

"There's a lot of talk about negotiations, but it's an illusion," says Mykhailo Podolyak, advisor to the head of President Zelensky's office.

"No negotiation process can take place because Russia has not been made to pay a high enough price for this war."

Zelensky's 'smart strategy exercise'

For all Kyiv's misgivings about negotiating while Russian forces continue their inexorable advance in the east, it's clear that President Zelensky is anxious to position himself as the sort of man Trump can do business with.

The Ukrainian leader was quick to congratulate Trump on his election victory and wasted little time sending senior officials to meet the president-elect's team.

With the help of France's President Emmanuel Macron, Zelensky also secured a meeting with Trump when the two men visited Paris for the reopening of Notre Dame cathedral.

"What we're seeing now is a very smart strategy exercise by President Zelensky," his former foreign minister Dmytro Kuleba told the US Council on Foreign Relations in December.

Zelensky, he said, was "signalling constructiveness and readiness to engage with President Trump."

With little obvious sign that the Kremlin is making similar gestures, the government in Kyiv is clearly trying to get ahead of the game.

"Because Trump hasn't fully explained how he's going to go about it, Ukrainians are trying to give him some ideas that he may present as his own," says Orysia Lutsevych, head of the Ukraine Forum at Chatham House.

"They know how to work with that ego."

The Victory Plan: possible endgames

Ukrainian leader's Victory Plan - NATO membership and its call for a "comprehensive non-nuclear strategic deterrence package" - seem to have met with a lukewarm response among Kyiv's allies.

NATO membership in particular remains a sticking point, as it has been since well before Russia's full-scale invasion.

For Kyiv, it's the only way to guarantee the country's future survival, against a rapacious Russian enemy bent on subjugating Ukraine.

President Zelensky has indicated that if an offer of membership was extended to the whole country, within Ukraine's internationally-recognised borders, he would be willing to accept that it would apply, initially, only to territory under Kyiv's control.

This, he told Sky News in November, could end the "hot stage" of the war, allowing a diplomatic process to address the question of Ukraine's final borders.

But, he said, no such offer had yet been made.

Kyiv's shaky position

Andriy Yermak, head of President Zelensky's office, said that Ukraine's recent past had left a bitter legacy. "Unfortunately, from our experience, all the guarantees we had before did not result in security."

Without concrete mechanisms akin to the sort of collective defence concept embodied by Article 5 of NATO's founding treaty, observers fear there will be nothing to prevent another Russian attack.

"Zelensky understands that he cannot just have a naked ceasefire," Orysia Lutsevych says.

"It has to be a ceasefire plus. It would be suicide for Zelensky just to accept a ceasefire and not to have any answer how Ukraine is protected."

"What alternative could there be? There are no alternatives today," says Mr Podolyak.

Pieces of paper, like the 1994 Budapest Memorandum (about Ukraine's post-Soviet borders) or 2014-15 Minsk agreements (which sought to end the Donbas War) are worthless, he argues, without the added threat of military deterrence.

"Russia must understand that as soon as they start aggression, they will receive a significant number of strikes in response," he says.

Britain, Biden and the role of the West

In the absence of agreement on Ukraine's long term future, its allies are doing what they can to bolster its defences.

In December, NATO's secretary general, Mark Rutte, said "everything" was being looked at, including the supply of additional air defence systems, in part to protect the country's battered energy infrastructure from a renewed wave of coordinated Russian missile and drone attacks.

With Ukraine continuing to experience severe shortages of manpower, the UK Defence Secretary John Healey said the government might be willing to send British troops to Ukraine to help with training.

For its part, the departing Biden administration seems determined to deliver as much congressionally approved military assistance as it can to Ukraine before leaving office, although reports suggest it may run out of time to send everything.

On December 21, it was reported that Trump would continue to supply military aid to Ukraine, but would demand that NATO members dramatically increase their defence spending.

Kyiv's allies have also continued to ratchet up sanctions on Moscow, in the hope that Russia's war-time economy, which has proved stubbornly resilient, may finally break.

"There's been deep frustration that sanctions haven't just shattered the Russian economy beyond repair," a US congressional source said, on condition of anonymity.

After multiple rounds of sanctions (fifteen from the EU alone), government officials have grown wary of predicting their successful impact.

But recent indicators are increasingly alarming for the Kremlin. With interest rates at 23 per cent, inflation running above 9 per cent, a falling rouble and growth expected to slow dramatically in 2025, the strains on Russia's economy have rarely seemed more acute.

Putin is putting on a brave face. "The sanctions are having an effect," he said during his end of year news conference, "but they are not of key importance."

Along with Russia's staggering losses on the battlefield – western officials estimate that Moscow is losing an average of 1,500 men, killed and wounded, every day – the cost of this war could yet drive Putin to the negotiating table.

But how much more territory will Ukraine have lost - and how many more people will have been killed - by the time that point is reached?

Source: BBC

Bd-pratidin English/Fariha Nowshin Chinika

More News
Pacific nations perplexed, worried by Trump tariffs
Pacific nations perplexed, worried by Trump tariffs
Israel turns two-thirds of Gaza into no-go zones: UN
Israel turns two-thirds of Gaza into no-go zones: UN
Europe discontent over Russia for rejecting Trump's truce push
Europe discontent over Russia for rejecting Trump's truce push
7 killed in deadly US tornado
7 killed in deadly US tornado
US tariffs a 'significant risk' to global economy: IMF
US tariffs a 'significant risk' to global economy: IMF
Trump unveils first $5 million 'gold card' visa
Trump unveils first $5 million 'gold card' visa
Israel kills at least 112 Palestinians in past 24 hours
Israel kills at least 112 Palestinians in past 24 hours
Deadly fire on Gaza ambulances possible Israeli 'war crimes': UN official
Deadly fire on Gaza ambulances possible Israeli 'war crimes': UN official
South Korea's Constitutional Court ousts impeached President Yoon
South Korea's Constitutional Court ousts impeached President Yoon
Turkiye condemns Israel as greatest threat to regional peace
Turkiye condemns Israel as greatest threat to regional peace
India says 'examining the implications' of US tariffs
India says 'examining the implications' of US tariffs
Russia, Cuba, North Korea escape Trump's tariff
Russia, Cuba, North Korea escape Trump's tariff
Latest News
NCP ready to take challenge to contest in 300 seats: Sarjis
NCP ready to take challenge to contest in 300 seats: Sarjis
8 minutes ago | National
CA holds bilateral meeting with Sri Lankan premier
CA holds bilateral meeting with Sri Lankan premier
9 minutes ago | National
Security 'breakdown' allows armed men into Melbourne's MCG
Security 'breakdown' allows armed men into Melbourne's MCG
13 minutes ago | Sports
Hridoy poised to succeed Tamim as Mohammedan Captain
Hridoy poised to succeed Tamim as Mohammedan Captain
28 minutes ago | Sports
Pacific nations perplexed, worried by Trump tariffs
Pacific nations perplexed, worried by Trump tariffs
50 minutes ago | International
Israel turns two-thirds of Gaza into no-go zones: UN
Israel turns two-thirds of Gaza into no-go zones: UN
57 minutes ago | International
Mass grave of Roman-era fighters uncovered in Vienna
Mass grave of Roman-era fighters uncovered in Vienna
1 hour ago | Tech
Prof. Yunus presents photograph to Modi
Prof. Yunus presents photograph to Modi
1 hour ago | National
BIMSTEC secretary general meets CA
BIMSTEC secretary general meets CA
1 hour ago | National
Yunus-Modi meeting fruitful: Press Secretary
Yunus-Modi meeting fruitful: Press Secretary
1 hour ago | National
Europe discontent over Russia for rejecting Trump's truce push
Europe discontent over Russia for rejecting Trump's truce push
1 hour ago | International
7 killed in deadly US tornado
7 killed in deadly US tornado
1 hour ago | International
IMF team to arrive in Dhaka tomorrow
IMF team to arrive in Dhaka tomorrow
2 hours ago | National
Extortion fuels unrest in CHT: Home Adviser
Extortion fuels unrest in CHT: Home Adviser
2 hours ago | National
US tariffs a 'significant risk' to global economy: IMF
US tariffs a 'significant risk' to global economy: IMF
2 hours ago | International
CA holds bilateral talks with Bhutan PM
CA holds bilateral talks with Bhutan PM
2 hours ago | National
Trump unveils first $5 million 'gold card' visa
Trump unveils first $5 million 'gold card' visa
2 hours ago | International
Key decisions ahead for Proteas and Aussies before WTC final
Key decisions ahead for Proteas and Aussies before WTC final
3 hours ago | Sports
Bangladesh, Thailand sign MoU to jointly combat corruption
Bangladesh, Thailand sign MoU to jointly combat corruption
3 hours ago | National
CA seeks Thai elite’s support for ASEAN membership
CA seeks Thai elite’s support for ASEAN membership
3 hours ago | National
Veteran Bollywood actor Manoj Kumar dies
Veteran Bollywood actor Manoj Kumar dies
3 hours ago | Entertainment
Mild to moderate heat wave sweeps over many districts
Mild to moderate heat wave sweeps over many districts
4 hours ago | National
Hasina’s extradition, border, water issues featured in Dr Yunus-Modi first-ever talks
Hasina’s extradition, border, water issues featured in Dr Yunus-Modi first-ever talks
4 hours ago | National
Bangladesh set for relentless cricket calendar through early 2027
Bangladesh set for relentless cricket calendar through early 2027
4 hours ago | Sports
Israel kills at least 112 Palestinians in past 24 hours
Israel kills at least 112 Palestinians in past 24 hours
4 hours ago | International
Japan PM Ishiba says Trump tariffs 'national crisis'
Japan PM Ishiba says Trump tariffs 'national crisis'
5 hours ago | Business
CA seeks humanitarian channel in Rakhine to stop further displacement
CA seeks humanitarian channel in Rakhine to stop further displacement
6 hours ago | National
Country’s export sector in deep crisis amid 37% US tariff
Country’s export sector in deep crisis amid 37% US tariff
6 hours ago | Business
Bangladesh to chair BIMSTEC for 2 years
Bangladesh to chair BIMSTEC for 2 years
7 hours ago | National
CA joins breakfast meeting on BIMSTEC sidelines
CA joins breakfast meeting on BIMSTEC sidelines
8 hours ago | National
Most Read
Dhaka's air 'unhealthy' today
Dhaka's air 'unhealthy' today
9 hours ago | City
Hasina’s extradition, border, water issues featured in Dr Yunus-Modi first-ever talks
Hasina’s extradition, border, water issues featured in Dr Yunus-Modi first-ever talks
4 hours ago | National
Mymensingh youth who participated in Ukraine war for Russia dies
Mymensingh youth who participated in Ukraine war for Russia dies
20 hours ago | National
Turkiye condemns Israel as greatest threat to regional peace
Turkiye condemns Israel as greatest threat to regional peace
9 hours ago | International
CA joins official dinner of BIMSTEC
CA joins official dinner of BIMSTEC
23 hours ago | National
‘Evidence of conspiracy to thwart July-August trial found’
‘Evidence of conspiracy to thwart July-August trial found’
22 hours ago | National
Bangladesh to chair BIMSTEC for 2 years
Bangladesh to chair BIMSTEC for 2 years
7 hours ago | National
Trump uses wrong allegations to justify tariff hikes on Bangladesh
Trump uses wrong allegations to justify tariff hikes on Bangladesh
22 hours ago | Business
Country’s export sector in deep crisis amid 37% US tariff
Country’s export sector in deep crisis amid 37% US tariff
6 hours ago | Business
Holding polls at earliest possible time top priority: CA
Holding polls at earliest possible time top priority: CA
8 hours ago | National
Gold price declines after hitting all-time high on Trump tariffs
Gold price declines after hitting all-time high on Trump tariffs
22 hours ago | Business
Kagiso Rabada leaves Gujarat Titans squad for personal reasons
Kagiso Rabada leaves Gujarat Titans squad for personal reasons
22 hours ago | Sports
CA to hold bilateral talks with Modi, other BIMSTEC leaders tomorrow
CA to hold bilateral talks with Modi, other BIMSTEC leaders tomorrow
20 hours ago | National
Dhaka weather to stay consistent until noon
Dhaka weather to stay consistent until noon
9 hours ago | City
BIMSTEC Secretary General calls on Touhid
BIMSTEC Secretary General calls on Touhid
23 hours ago | National
Over 100,000 child deaths, 63,000 stillbirths annually in Bangladesh
Over 100,000 child deaths, 63,000 stillbirths annually in Bangladesh
23 hours ago | National
Rescue team led by Bangladesh Army continues its operation in Myanmar
Rescue team led by Bangladesh Army continues its operation in Myanmar
21 hours ago | National
White House releases AFTP report, signaling major shift in US trade policy
White House releases AFTP report, signaling major shift in US trade policy
9 hours ago | Business
Deadly fire on Gaza ambulances possible Israeli 'war crimes': UN official
Deadly fire on Gaza ambulances possible Israeli 'war crimes': UN official
8 hours ago | International
Russia, Cuba, North Korea escape Trump's tariff
Russia, Cuba, North Korea escape Trump's tariff
23 hours ago | International
Elizabeth Strout, Miranda July shortlisted for Women's Prize for Fiction
Elizabeth Strout, Miranda July shortlisted for Women's Prize for Fiction
19 hours ago | Lifestyle
Tariff issue to be resolved through talks with US: CA
Tariff issue to be resolved through talks with US: CA
21 hours ago | National
Bangladesh, Thailand sign MoU to jointly combat corruption
Bangladesh, Thailand sign MoU to jointly combat corruption
3 hours ago | National
Trump's tariffs dull the dollar's safe-haven sheen
Trump's tariffs dull the dollar's safe-haven sheen
23 hours ago | Business
India says 'examining the implications' of US tariffs
India says 'examining the implications' of US tariffs
22 hours ago | International
Israel kills at least 112 Palestinians in past 24 hours
Israel kills at least 112 Palestinians in past 24 hours
4 hours ago | International
Thai ministers meet CA on BIMSTEC sidelines
Thai ministers meet CA on BIMSTEC sidelines
21 hours ago | National
CA seeks humanitarian channel in Rakhine to stop further displacement
CA seeks humanitarian channel in Rakhine to stop further displacement
6 hours ago | National
Bangladesh set for relentless cricket calendar through early 2027
Bangladesh set for relentless cricket calendar through early 2027
4 hours ago | Sports
Interim government can't be failed: Tuku
Interim government can't be failed: Tuku
21 hours ago | National