Publish: 08:44, 11 Mar, 2025

Jury rules Disney didn’t copy Moana from surfer story

Online Desk
Jury rules Disney didn’t copy Moana from surfer story
Photo - Collected

A jury has swiftly and unequivocally dismissed claims that Disney’s Moana was derived from a story about a young surfer in Hawaii.

On Monday, a federal jury in Los Angeles deliberated for just two and a half hours before concluding that the creators of Moana had no access to writer and animator Buck Woodall’s outlines and script for Bucky the Surfer Boy, reports UNB.

With this issue resolved, the jury of six women and two men did not need to examine the similarities between Bucky and Disney’s 2016 animated feature, which follows the journey of a Polynesian princess.

Woodall had shared his work with a distant relative who worked for a separate company on the Disney lot. However, during the two-week trial, she testified that she had never shown it to anyone at Disney.

“Obviously, we’re disappointed,” Woodall’s attorney, Gustavo Lage, said outside the courtroom. “We’re going to review our options and consider the best way forward.”

In closing arguments earlier that day, Woodall’s attorney asserted that an extensive chain of circumstantial evidence linked the two works inseparably.

“There was no Moana without Bucky,” Lage argued.

Defence lawyer Moez Kaba countered that the evidence overwhelmingly demonstrated that Moana was the original work and the “crowning achievement” of John Musker and Ron Clements, the celebrated writers and directors behind The Little Mermaid (1989), Aladdin (1992), Hercules (1997), and The Princess and the Frog (2009).

“They had no idea about Bucky,” Kaba stated in his closing remarks. “They had never seen it, never heard of it.”

Moana went on to earn nearly $700 million worldwide.

A judge had previously ruled that Woodall’s 2020 lawsuit was filed too late for him to claim any share of the film’s revenue. Additionally, a separate lawsuit he filed earlier this year regarding Moana 2—which grossed over $1 billion—must be addressed separately. Though that case remains active, the jury’s decision does not bode well for its outcome. Judge Consuelo B. Marshall, who is also presiding over the sequel lawsuit, expressed agreement with the jury’s verdict regarding access.

“We are incredibly proud of the collective effort that went into making Moana and are pleased that the jury determined it had no connection to the plaintiff’s work,” Disney said in a statement.

Bd-pratidin English/ Afia

More News
Veteran actress Gulshan Ara Ahmed passes away
Veteran actress Gulshan Ara Ahmed passes away
Sharmila Tagore returns in 'Puratawn', a tale of aging and family bonds
Sharmila Tagore returns in 'Puratawn', a tale of aging and family bonds
“I’m just an actor”: Akshay Kumar on ‘Kesari 2’ political row
“I’m just an actor”: Akshay Kumar on ‘Kesari 2’ political row
Actor-politician Vijay moves Supreme Court against Waqf Act
Actor-politician Vijay moves Supreme Court against Waqf Act
Malika Sherawat has 'silicon in her chest': Aditi Rao
Malika Sherawat has 'silicon in her chest': Aditi Rao
Aamir with girlfriend Gauri showcase traditional glamour at Macau festival
Aamir with girlfriend Gauri showcase traditional glamour at Macau festival
CID hints at ACP Pradyuman's comeback
CID hints at ACP Pradyuman's comeback
Cruise’s Ethan Hunt role may face dramatic end
Cruise’s Ethan Hunt role may face dramatic end
Pakistani singer Mustafa Zahid’s concert abruptly postponed
Pakistani singer Mustafa Zahid’s concert abruptly postponed
‘Sharmila diagnosed with cancer, treated without chemo’
‘Sharmila diagnosed with cancer, treated without chemo’
Om Puri confessed his affair a day before his wedding to Seema Kapoor
Om Puri confessed his affair a day before his wedding to Seema Kapoor
Oscars to add stunt design award for its 100th ceremony
Oscars to add stunt design award for its 100th ceremony
Latest News
US high-level delegation due Wednesday
US high-level delegation due Wednesday
8 hours ago | National
British citizen dies after falling at Roman aqueduct in Spain
British citizen dies after falling at Roman aqueduct in Spain
8 hours ago | International
Singaporeans will go to the polls on May 3
Singaporeans will go to the polls on May 3
8 hours ago | International
Hamas rejects Israeli ceasefire disarmament proposal
Hamas rejects Israeli ceasefire disarmament proposal
8 hours ago | International
BNP wants removal of ambiguity over polls time in meeting with CA
BNP wants removal of ambiguity over polls time in meeting with CA
8 hours ago | National
Dhaka seeks stronger S. Asian ties under pro-Bangladesh foreign policy
Dhaka seeks stronger S. Asian ties under pro-Bangladesh foreign policy
9 hours ago | National
KUET students unlock halls, demand VC’s quit
KUET students unlock halls, demand VC’s quit
9 hours ago | National
Bangladesh to graduate from LDC status in 2026
Bangladesh to graduate from LDC status in 2026
9 hours ago | National
SK Bashir appointed as civil aviation and tourism adviser
SK Bashir appointed as civil aviation and tourism adviser
10 hours ago | National
Have to move at full speed towards LDC graduation: CA
Have to move at full speed towards LDC graduation: CA
10 hours ago | National
Kings battle past Rahmatganj to reach final
Kings battle past Rahmatganj to reach final
10 hours ago | Sports
BNP now demands for swift election: Ishraque
BNP now demands for swift election: Ishraque
11 hours ago | National
DUCSU election roadmap announced
DUCSU election roadmap announced
11 hours ago | City
Master plan for modern waste management on cards: Rizwana
Master plan for modern waste management on cards: Rizwana
11 hours ago | National
Bangladesh mission in Canada celebrates Pahela Baishakh
Bangladesh mission in Canada celebrates Pahela Baishakh
12 hours ago | National
Tulip to face Interpol red alert if she skips court hearing
Tulip to face Interpol red alert if she skips court hearing
12 hours ago | National
Trump blames Zelensky for starting war after Russian attack
Trump blames Zelensky for starting war after Russian attack
12 hours ago | International
Maldives ban Israelis to protest war
Maldives ban Israelis to protest war
12 hours ago | International
Expats send $1.05bn remittances in 12 days of April
Expats send $1.05bn remittances in 12 days of April
13 hours ago | National
‘It’s people who support 5-year interim govt’
‘It’s people who support 5-year interim govt’
13 hours ago | National
BNP to meet Chief Adviser tomorrow
BNP to meet Chief Adviser tomorrow
13 hours ago | National
India to tour Bangladesh for white-ball series in August
India to tour Bangladesh for white-ball series in August
13 hours ago | Sports
Court freezes Tk 54cr BO share of ex-secretary’s son
Court freezes Tk 54cr BO share of ex-secretary’s son
14 hours ago | National
300 killed as Sudanese war approaches 2nd year
300 killed as Sudanese war approaches 2nd year
14 hours ago | International
How much does a brief space trip cost?
How much does a brief space trip cost?
15 hours ago | Tech
OpenAI unveils GPT-4.1 API for developers with coding capabilities
OpenAI unveils GPT-4.1 API for developers with coding capabilities
15 hours ago | Tech
Finance Ministry issues outsourcing service procurement policy
Finance Ministry issues outsourcing service procurement policy
15 hours ago | National
Arrest warrant against Hasina, Joy, 27 others
Arrest warrant against Hasina, Joy, 27 others
15 hours ago | National
Top 10 fruits to trim belly fat
Top 10 fruits to trim belly fat
15 hours ago | Lifestyle
Mild heat wave persists in parts of Bangladesh, rain likely in some regions
Mild heat wave persists in parts of Bangladesh, rain likely in some regions
15 hours ago | National
Most Read
Bangladesh, Singapore vow to expand cooperation
Bangladesh, Singapore vow to expand cooperation
21 hours ago | National
Bangladesh, Türkiye seek to elevate bilateral ties
Bangladesh, Türkiye seek to elevate bilateral ties
21 hours ago | National
Blue Origin’s all-female crew safely returns to Earth
Blue Origin’s all-female crew safely returns to Earth
20 hours ago | Tech
Common goal for state reform, minor differences in execution: Ali Riaz
Common goal for state reform, minor differences in execution: Ali Riaz
17 hours ago | National
Sharmila Tagore returns in 'Puratawn', a tale of aging and family bonds
Sharmila Tagore returns in 'Puratawn', a tale of aging and family bonds
18 hours ago | Entertainment
Meta to train AI models using public content in the EU
Meta to train AI models using public content in the EU
20 hours ago | Tech
Bourses extend losses as trading resumes after holiday break
Bourses extend losses as trading resumes after holiday break
15 hours ago | Business
How much does a brief space trip cost?
How much does a brief space trip cost?
15 hours ago | Tech
Veteran actress Gulshan Ara Ahmed passes away
Veteran actress Gulshan Ara Ahmed passes away
17 hours ago | Entertainment
Power nutrient vitamin E for immunity, heart, and glowing skin
Power nutrient vitamin E for immunity, heart, and glowing skin
19 hours ago | Lifestyle
Bangladesh High Commission in Delhi celebrates Pahela Baishakh
Bangladesh High Commission in Delhi celebrates Pahela Baishakh
19 hours ago | International
OpenAI unveils GPT-4.1 API for developers with coding capabilities
OpenAI unveils GPT-4.1 API for developers with coding capabilities
15 hours ago | Tech
Finance Ministry issues outsourcing service procurement policy
Finance Ministry issues outsourcing service procurement policy
15 hours ago | National
Mild heat wave persists in parts of Bangladesh, rain likely in some regions
Mild heat wave persists in parts of Bangladesh, rain likely in some regions
15 hours ago | National
Explore benefits of retro walking
Explore benefits of retro walking
19 hours ago | Lifestyle
Titas Gas to begin smart prepaid metre installations from 2026
Titas Gas to begin smart prepaid metre installations from 2026
20 hours ago | National
Who built one eleven and why it still matters
Who built one eleven and why it still matters
18 hours ago | Special
Russia's IT sector fears re-entry of Western competitors
Russia's IT sector fears re-entry of Western competitors
16 hours ago | International
South Korea unveils $23bn chip support amid US tariff uncertainty
South Korea unveils $23bn chip support amid US tariff uncertainty
19 hours ago | Business
58-day ban on fishing in sea begins
58-day ban on fishing in sea begins
18 hours ago | National
Harvard sees $2.2 billion in funding frozen after defying Trump
Harvard sees $2.2 billion in funding frozen after defying Trump
20 hours ago | International
Have to move at full speed towards LDC graduation: CA
Have to move at full speed towards LDC graduation: CA
10 hours ago | National
Apple dominates global smartphone market in Q1 2025
Apple dominates global smartphone market in Q1 2025
18 hours ago | Tech
Probe report in Sagar-Runi murder case on May 21
Probe report in Sagar-Runi murder case on May 21
16 hours ago | National
Saudi bans non-Hajj visitors in Makkah hotels during pilgrimage season
Saudi bans non-Hajj visitors in Makkah hotels during pilgrimage season
21 hours ago | International
UAE announces resumption of flights to Syria
UAE announces resumption of flights to Syria
20 hours ago | International
Hungary enshrines only two genders in constitution, defying EU policies
Hungary enshrines only two genders in constitution, defying EU policies
19 hours ago | International
Arrest warrant against Hasina, Joy, 27 others
Arrest warrant against Hasina, Joy, 27 others
15 hours ago | National
Trump’s trade war with China could be good for India: NY Times
Trump’s trade war with China could be good for India: NY Times
18 hours ago | Business
Glitter with purpose: Weighing emotion and investment in gold
Glitter with purpose: Weighing emotion and investment in gold
20 hours ago | Business