Publish: 13:25, 02 Nov, 2024

Pennsylvania challenge of Elon Musk's $1M-a-day voter sweepstakes moves back to state court

Online Desk
Pennsylvania challenge of Elon Musk's $1M-a-day voter sweepstakes moves back to state court
Photo - Collected

A legal fight over Elon Musk’s $1 million-a-day voter sweepstakes is back in state court in Pennsylvania, a loss for the billionaire, after a federal judge said Friday that he doesn't have jurisdiction, reports AP.

Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner wants to keep his fight to shut down the giveaways in state court, calling it a violation of state lottery laws. Musk had argued that the case belonged in federal court as it involves claims of federal election interference. A judge scheduled a hearing for 10 a.m. Monday. It wasn't immediately clear whether Musk would attend though Krasner previously argued that Musk should have to appear in court.

Musk’s political organization, which aims to boost Donald Trump’s presidential campaign, has organized the sweepstakes as a way of encouraging people to be registered voters in key battleground states.

With just days to go until Tuesday's presidential election, the case now returns to Judge Angelo Foglietta, who held a brief hearing Thursday in a courtroom at Philadelphia City Hall. No further hearings were immediately scheduled.

U.S. District Judge Gerald J. Pappert, a Republican former Pennsylvania attorney general appointed to the federal bench by President Barack Obama, issued Friday's ruling.

"Defendants argue the complaint’s references to ‘the forthcoming Federal Presidential Election’ show the lawsuit necessarily raises questions of federal law. But federal question jurisdiction does not turn on a plaintiff’s motivations in filing suit; it turns on whether the legal issues arising from the claims originate in federal or state law,” Pappert wrote.

Krasner lawyer John Summers, in a statement, said he will now ask Foglietta “to enter an injunction to stop the defendants’ lottery and the defendants’ unfair and deceptive practices.” Matthew Haverstick, a lawyer for Musk, did not immediately respond to text and phone messages seeking comment.

Musk, who owns Tesla, SpaceX and X, has gone all in on Trump this election, saying he thinks civilization is at stake. He is undertaking much of the get-out-the-vote effort for Trump through his super PAC, which can raise and spend unlimited sums of money. He has committed more than $70 million to the super PAC to help Trump and other Republicans win in November.

Krasner accused Musk and his PAC in his lawsuit filed Monday of running a dubious lottery in the tense run-up to Tuesday’s election. Four of the first dozen winners appeared to be from Pennsylvania, perhaps the key prize in the tight presidential race between Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris.

“Is it just a coincidence that this is the state that has the largest electoral votes? I don’t think so,” lawyer John Summers argued Thursday.

Posts by Musk’s America PAC on his X platform indicate he’s given away 13 checks of $1 million since the first one in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, on Oct. 19. Other winners came from the battleground states of Wisconsin, Nevada, Arizona, Georgia, North Carolina and Michigan. The sweepstakes is set to run through Election Day, open to registered voters in too-close-to-call states who sign a petition supporting the Constitution.

“They’re doing things in the dark,” Summers told the judge. “We don’t know the rules being followed. We don’t know how they’re supposedly picking people at random … It’s an outrage.”

Election law experts have questioned whether it violates federal law barring payments for votes. Musk has cast the money as both a prize as well as earnings for work as a spokesperson for the group.

Krasner has said he could still consider criminal charges, as he’s tasked with protecting both lotteries and the integrity of elections.

Both Trump and Kamala Harris have made repeated visits to the state as they fight for Pennsylvania’s 19 electoral votes, and both plan several more stops there before Tuesday.

bd-pratidin/Rafid

More News
Former UK Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott dies at age 86
Former UK Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott dies at age 86
Putin gifts over 70 animals to North Korean zoo following troop support for Russian army
Putin gifts over 70 animals to North Korean zoo following troop support for Russian army
4 foreign tourists die from methanol tainted alcohol in Laos
4 foreign tourists die from methanol tainted alcohol in Laos
Ukraine says Russia has launched an ICBM in an attack
Ukraine says Russia has launched an ICBM in an attack
Iran slams US’ veto on Gaza ceasefire resolution
Iran slams US’ veto on Gaza ceasefire resolution
Angela Merkel reveals strategies for dealing with Donald Trump in ‘Memoir’
Angela Merkel reveals strategies for dealing with Donald Trump in ‘Memoir’
UN decides holding high-level conference on Rohingya next year
UN decides holding high-level conference on Rohingya next year
Adani charged in US over massive bribery scheme
Adani charged in US over massive bribery scheme
Ukraine reportedly fires UK 'Storm Shadow' missiles into Russia
Ukraine reportedly fires UK 'Storm Shadow' missiles into Russia
Israeli attack on Syria kills 36
Israeli attack on Syria kills 36
Magnitude 5.2 earthquake hits Panama
Magnitude 5.2 earthquake hits Panama
US vetoes on Gaza ceasefire resolution
US vetoes on Gaza ceasefire resolution
Latest News
Dengue takes 9 lives in 24 hrs
Dengue takes 9 lives in 24 hrs

15 minutes ago | National

Govt unveils treatment plan for injured in July-August movement
Govt unveils treatment plan for injured in July-August movement

35 minutes ago | National

Battery rickshaw blockade suspended until Saturday
Battery rickshaw blockade suspended until Saturday

39 minutes ago | National

Akbar to be banned for two NCL matches
Akbar to be banned for two NCL matches

1 hour ago | Sports

Two bodies recovered in Naogaon
Two bodies recovered in Naogaon

1 hour ago | City

Chief Advisor proud bringing Khaleda Zia to Senakunja
Chief Advisor proud bringing Khaleda Zia to Senakunja

1 hour ago | National

Opportunities created to decrease fuel oil price further: BPC chairman
Opportunities created to decrease fuel oil price further: BPC chairman

1 hour ago | Economy

I believe in free, fair, and credible election: CEC
I believe in free, fair, and credible election: CEC

1 hour ago | National

Shafik Rehman secures bail
Shafik Rehman secures bail

2 hours ago | National

Former UK Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott dies at age 86
Former UK Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott dies at age 86

2 hours ago | International

Khaleda Zia makes first public appearance at Senakunja in 12 years
Khaleda Zia makes first public appearance at Senakunja in 12 years

2 hours ago | National

Putin gifts over 70 animals to North Korean zoo following troop support for Russian army
Putin gifts over 70 animals to North Korean zoo following troop support for Russian army

2 hours ago | International

4 foreign tourists die from methanol tainted alcohol in Laos
4 foreign tourists die from methanol tainted alcohol in Laos

2 hours ago | International

Supreme Court stays ex-Addl AG Mehedi’s bail
Supreme Court stays ex-Addl AG Mehedi’s bail

2 hours ago | National

Farmers busy in harvesting paddy in Naogaon
Farmers busy in harvesting paddy in Naogaon

3 hours ago | City

Ukraine says Russia has launched an ICBM in an attack
Ukraine says Russia has launched an ICBM in an attack

3 hours ago | International

No artificial crisis be allowed in food supply chain: Bashir
No artificial crisis be allowed in food supply chain: Bashir

3 hours ago | City

Nasir Uddin appointed as new CEC, along with four others
Nasir Uddin appointed as new CEC, along with four others

3 hours ago | National

Garment workers block road in Gazipur protesting
Garment workers block road in Gazipur protesting

3 hours ago | City

Dr. Yunus advocates for a country where people hold ultimate power
Dr. Yunus advocates for a country where people hold ultimate power

4 hours ago | National

New DMP Commissioner Sazzad Ali takes charge
New DMP Commissioner Sazzad Ali takes charge

4 hours ago | City

Shakib hints he might be available for Windies ODIs
Shakib hints he might be available for Windies ODIs

4 hours ago | Sports

Iran slams US’ veto on Gaza ceasefire resolution
Iran slams US’ veto on Gaza ceasefire resolution

4 hours ago | International

Robert Pattinson cast in Christopher Nolan's next film
Robert Pattinson cast in Christopher Nolan's next film

4 hours ago | Showbiz

Georgia mom charged as son walks alone
Georgia mom charged as son walks alone

5 hours ago | Lifestyle

Ex-MP Shahjahan  arrested
Ex-MP Shahjahan arrested

5 hours ago | National

South Korea donates $2mn to support WFP’s Rohingya food aid in Bangladesh
South Korea donates $2mn to support WFP’s Rohingya food aid in Bangladesh

5 hours ago | Economy

Barrister Suman shifted to Habiganj jail
Barrister Suman shifted to Habiganj jail

5 hours ago | National

Bhutanese Ambassador and BNP leader Fakhrul discuss SAARC revival
Bhutanese Ambassador and BNP leader Fakhrul discuss SAARC revival

5 hours ago | National

Sohanur Rahman honored with YAS24 Award in Geneva
Sohanur Rahman honored with YAS24 Award in Geneva

5 hours ago | National

Most Read
Armed Forces Day: Traffic restrictions in Dhaka Cantonment today
Armed Forces Day: Traffic restrictions in Dhaka Cantonment today

9 hours ago | City

Russia to provide 30,000 MT of fertilizer to Bangladesh free of charge
Russia to provide 30,000 MT of fertilizer to Bangladesh free of charge

5 hours ago | National

New IGP, DMP commissioner appointed
New IGP, DMP commissioner appointed

23 hours ago | National

Response to Israeli strikes on Beirut will be on ‘central Tel Aviv’: Hezbollah chief
Response to Israeli strikes on Beirut will be on ‘central Tel Aviv’: Hezbollah chief

21 hours ago | International

‘Provision of appeal against order of ICT to ensure fair trial’
‘Provision of appeal against order of ICT to ensure fair trial’

5 hours ago | National

Rizwana for coordination between financial institutions, development partners
Rizwana for coordination between financial institutions, development partners

23 hours ago | National

US vetoes on Gaza ceasefire resolution
US vetoes on Gaza ceasefire resolution

8 hours ago | International

Yemeni forces seize Israeli ship in fresh operation
Yemeni forces seize Israeli ship in fresh operation

10 hours ago | International

24 Bangladeshis return after 2-year jail term in India
24 Bangladeshis return after 2-year jail term in India

8 hours ago | National

Jamaat Ameer returns country from UK
Jamaat Ameer returns country from UK

7 hours ago | National

Nasir Uddin appointed as new CEC, along with four others
Nasir Uddin appointed as new CEC, along with four others

3 hours ago | National

Armed Forces to continue collaboration with people to safeguard independence: CA
Armed Forces to continue collaboration with people to safeguard independence: CA

21 hours ago | National

Khaleda Zia to join Armed Forces Day reception at Senakunja
Khaleda Zia to join Armed Forces Day reception at Senakunja

10 hours ago | National

Rickshaw drivers block railway line, disrupt communication with Dhaka
Rickshaw drivers block railway line, disrupt communication with Dhaka

6 hours ago | City

Barrister Suman shifted to Habiganj jail
Barrister Suman shifted to Habiganj jail

5 hours ago | National

Indian FS leads Delhi at Bangladesh-India FOC next month: Touhid
Indian FS leads Delhi at Bangladesh-India FOC next month: Touhid

22 hours ago | National

Bangladesh highlights adequate and quality Climate Finance at COP29
Bangladesh highlights adequate and quality Climate Finance at COP29

23 hours ago | National

Australia introduces 'Landmark' bill to ban social media for children under 16
Australia introduces 'Landmark' bill to ban social media for children under 16

7 hours ago | Tech

Angela Merkel reveals strategies for dealing with Donald Trump in ‘Memoir’
Angela Merkel reveals strategies for dealing with Donald Trump in ‘Memoir’

6 hours ago | International

Dr. Yunus advocates for a country where people hold ultimate power
Dr. Yunus advocates for a country where people hold ultimate power

4 hours ago | National

People to decide which party to do politics or join polls: Fakhrul
People to decide which party to do politics or join polls: Fakhrul

23 hours ago | National

Armed Forces Day being observed
Armed Forces Day being observed

8 hours ago | National

US regulators seek to break up Google, as part of punishment
US regulators seek to break up Google, as part of punishment

7 hours ago | Tech

Report on Bangladesh Pratidin: DNCC to repair road in front of Ziaur Rahman's plot
Report on Bangladesh Pratidin: DNCC to repair road in front of Ziaur Rahman's plot

8 hours ago | City

VR training tool to boost surgical skills of ophthalmologists
VR training tool to boost surgical skills of ophthalmologists

7 hours ago | National

Bangladesh keen to work closely with Trump administration: CA
Bangladesh keen to work closely with Trump administration: CA

6 hours ago | National

Trump made no mention of Sheikh Hasina's leadership in interview
Trump made no mention of Sheikh Hasina's leadership in interview

6 hours ago | National

UNICEF appoints 16-year-old Gargee as new youth advocate in Bangladesh
UNICEF appoints 16-year-old Gargee as new youth advocate in Bangladesh

9 hours ago | National

Microsoft to introduce voice cloning for teams meetings soon
Microsoft to introduce voice cloning for teams meetings soon

8 hours ago | Tech

Bangladesh ready to face West Indies in first test on Friday
Bangladesh ready to face West Indies in first test on Friday

7 hours ago | Sports