Publish: 13:32, 05 Feb, 2025

U.S. District Judge says

Elon Musk's claims of harm from OpenAI are a 'stretch'

Online Desk
Elon Musk's claims of harm from OpenAI are a 'stretch'
Elon Musk arrives before the 60th Presidential Inauguration in the Rotunda of the U.S. Capitol in Washington, Monday, Jan. 20, 2025. (Kevin Lamarque/Pool Photo via AP)

Elon Musk's lawyers faced off with OpenAI in court Tuesday as a federal judge weighed the billionaire's request for a court order that would block the ChatGPT maker from converting itself to a for-profit company.

U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers said it was a “stretch” for Musk to claim he will be irreparably harmed if she doesn't intervene to stop OpenAI from moving forward with its transition from a nonprofit research laboratory to a for-profit corporation.

But the judge also raised concerns about OpenAI and its relationship with business partner Microsoft and said she wouldn't stop the case from moving to trial as soon as next year so a jury can decide.

“It is plausible that what Mr. Musk is saying is true. We’ll find out. He’ll sit on the stand,” she said.

Musk, an early OpenAI investor and board member, sued the artificial intelligence company last year, first in a California state court and later in federal court, alleging it had betrayed its founding aims as a nonprofit research lab benefiting the public good. Musk had invested about $45 million in the startup from its founding until 2018, his lawyer said Tuesday.

Musk escalated the legal dispute late last year, adding new claims and defendants and asking for a court order that would stop OpenAI’s plans to convert itself into a for-profit business more fully. Musk also added his own AI company, xAI, as a plaintiff.

Also targeted by Musk's lawsuit is OpenAI's close business partner Microsoft and tech entrepreneur Reid Hoffman, a former OpenAI board member who also sits on Microsoft's board.

Gonzalez Rogers said she has a high bar for approving the kind of preliminary injunction that Musk wants but hasn't yet ruled on the request. She did say she had “significant concerns” with two people connected to Microsoft on OpenAI's board — Hoffman and longtime Microsoft executive Deanna Templeton, who was a “non-voting observer.”

“So you want me to believe that she was sitting there listening to all the discussions and not telling anybody? What would the point be for her to sit there and listen to everybody, if not to communicate what she was listening? There would be no point for her to be there, which is why she actually should not be there,” she said.

Hoffman, a co-founder of LinkedIn, has been on Microsoft’s board since shortly after the tech giant bought the job networking site. He stepped down from OpenAI's board in 2023 to avoid conflicts with his AI startup, Inflection.

Templeton, who Musk also named as a defendant, was added as a non-voting member of OpenAI’s board in the aftermath of Altman’s ouster after Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella sought more stability on the board. But months later, she was dropped from the OpenAI board as U.S. antitrust enforcers were expressing concerns about such arrangements on corporate boards.

The judge has handled a number of tech industry cases including Apple's fight with Epic Games, though she said Tuesday that Musk's case is “nothing like” that one. That case was also the last time she granted a preliminary injunction, in 2020, eight months before the case went to trial.

Then-President Barack Obama appointed Gonzalez Rogers to the federal bench in 2011.

Tuesday's hearing was originally set for January but was postponed after Musk's attorney Marc Toberoff said his house was destroyed in the Pacific Palisades wildfire.

Musk, who did not attend the hearing, has alleged in the lawsuit that the companies are violating the terms of his foundational contributions to the charity. Judge Gonzalez Rogers called it a “stretch” to claim “irreparable harm” to Musk, and called the case “billionaires vs. billionaires.” She questioned why Musk invested tens of millions in OpenAI without a written contract. Toberoff said it was because the relationship between Altman and Musk at the time was “built on trust” and the two were very close.

“That is just a lot of money” to invest “on a handshake,” the judge said.

OpenAI has said Musk’s requested court order would “debilitate OpenAI’s business” and mission to the advantage of Musk and his own AI company and is based on “far-fetched” legal claims.

At the heart of the dispute is a 2017 internal power struggle at the fledgling startup that led to Altman becoming OpenAI’s CEO.

Emails disclosed by OpenAI show Musk had also sought to be CEO and grew frustrated after two other OpenAI co-founders said he would hold too much power as a major shareholder and chief executive if the startup succeeded in its goal to achieve better-than-human AI known as artificial general intelligence, or AGI. Musk has long voiced concerns about how advanced forms of AI could threaten humanity.

Altman eventually succeeded in becoming CEO and has remained so except for a period in 2023 when he was fired and then reinstated days later after the board that ousted him was replaced.

OpenAI has sought to demonstrate Musk’s early support for the idea of making OpenAI a for-profit business so it could raise money for the hardware and computer power that AI needs.

Musk is not the only one challenging OpenAI's for-profit transition. Facebook and Instagram parent Meta Platforms has asked California's attorney general to block it, and the office of Delaware's attorney general has said it is reviewing the conversion.

It was not clear Tuesday when the case might go to trial. Musk's lawyers initially said they would be ready by June after some back-and-forth with the two sides the judge indicated it probably won't be until June 2026 at the earliest, but likely early 2027.

Source: AP

bd-pratidin/Rafid

More News
Meta starts testing its first in-house AI Chip
Meta starts testing its first in-house AI Chip
Apple gears up for major software overhaul
Apple gears up for major software overhaul
Elon Musk claims X targeted in ‘massive cyberattack’
Elon Musk claims X targeted in ‘massive cyberattack’
Nissan tests driverless cars on busy Japan city streets
Nissan tests driverless cars on busy Japan city streets
Thai man arrested for laundering money for call centre scam gangs
Thai man arrested for laundering money for call centre scam gangs
Australia’s first 3D-printed multi-storey house under construction in Wyndham
Australia’s first 3D-printed multi-storey house under construction in Wyndham
Starlink is ‘backbone’ of Ukrainian military – Musk
Starlink is ‘backbone’ of Ukrainian military – Musk
China to use AI in elder care as population ages: official
China to use AI in elder care as population ages: official
Trump vows support for crypto industry
Trump vows support for crypto industry
Artificial blood: Scientists progress in solving global shortages
Artificial blood: Scientists progress in solving global shortages
Bangladeshi firms join hands with US telecom giant Starlink
Bangladeshi firms join hands with US telecom giant Starlink
Study links brain activity at death to soul departing the body
Study links brain activity at death to soul departing the body
Latest News
Trump’s 25% tariffs on all steel and aluminum imports go into effect
Trump’s 25% tariffs on all steel and aluminum imports go into effect
7 seconds ago | International
Meta starts testing its first in-house AI Chip
Meta starts testing its first in-house AI Chip
6 minutes ago | Tech
Greenland votes under shadow of Trump
Greenland votes under shadow of Trump
10 minutes ago | International
Renowned entrepreneur Manzur Elahi passes away
Renowned entrepreneur Manzur Elahi passes away
15 minutes ago | Business
‘Harry Potter’ actor Simon Fisher dies
‘Harry Potter’ actor Simon Fisher dies
20 minutes ago | Entertainment
US resumes military aid as Ukraine says it is open to a 30-day ceasefire
US resumes military aid as Ukraine says it is open to a 30-day ceasefire
32 minutes ago | International
Govt agrees to provide monthly payments to non-MPO teachers
Govt agrees to provide monthly payments to non-MPO teachers
36 minutes ago | National
Mohakhali slum fire doused
Mohakhali slum fire doused
36 minutes ago | City
Govt mulls deferring LDC graduation
Govt mulls deferring LDC graduation
53 minutes ago | Business
DU students demand Lucky Akter's arrest
DU students demand Lucky Akter's arrest
53 minutes ago | National
Trump reverses tariff hike on Canada, sparking market turmoil
Trump reverses tariff hike on Canada, sparking market turmoil
1 hour ago | International
Ukraine ready to accept one month ceasefire with Russia
Ukraine ready to accept one month ceasefire with Russia
1 hour ago | International
Osmani’s Independence Award proposal dropped over precedence issue
Osmani’s Independence Award proposal dropped over precedence issue
1 hour ago | National
Does Liverpool’s Champions League exit to PSG reveal a flaw in the revamped competition?
Does Liverpool’s Champions League exit to PSG reveal a flaw in the revamped competition?
1 hour ago | Sports
Pakistan train attack: 104 passengers rescued, 16 killed
Pakistan train attack: 104 passengers rescued, 16 killed
1 hour ago | International
Court orders seizure of 54 kathas of Summit Group land
Court orders seizure of 54 kathas of Summit Group land
1 hour ago | National
Kane revels in a statement win for Bayern Munich in the Champions League
Kane revels in a statement win for Bayern Munich in the Champions League
1 hour ago | Sports
Armed Forces Must Not Be Dragged through the Dirt
Armed Forces Must Not Be Dragged through the Dirt
2 hours ago | Special
From 7.24% to 11.89%: Businesses alarmed by sharp rise in loan rates
From 7.24% to 11.89%: Businesses alarmed by sharp rise in loan rates
2 hours ago | Business
Army denounces false coup allegations by Indian media
Army denounces false coup allegations by Indian media
2 hours ago | National
‘Simultaneous legislative and constituent assembly elections possible’
‘Simultaneous legislative and constituent assembly elections possible’
12 hours ago | National
Focus on solving public issues, not just reforms: Tarique
Focus on solving public issues, not just reforms: Tarique
12 hours ago | National
Nearly 1,000 Civilian Deaths Over Three Years
Nearly 1,000 Civilian Deaths Over Three Years
12 hours ago | International
4 get life term for 2005 murder in Narayanganj
4 get life term for 2005 murder in Narayanganj
13 hours ago | National
Won’t see AL in country’s politics: Hasnat
Won’t see AL in country’s politics: Hasnat
13 hours ago | National
Helpline launched to address labour issues ahead of Eid
Helpline launched to address labour issues ahead of Eid
14 hours ago | National
INGOs urge prompt action against sexual violence in Bangladesh
INGOs urge prompt action against sexual violence in Bangladesh
14 hours ago | National
British envoy meets Jamaat Ameer
British envoy meets Jamaat Ameer
14 hours ago | National
Death toll from Ukraine drone attack on Russia rises to three: official
Death toll from Ukraine drone attack on Russia rises to three: official
14 hours ago | International
Australia, England to play historic 150th anniversary Test at MCG
Australia, England to play historic 150th anniversary Test at MCG
15 hours ago | Sports
Most Read
Bangladesh 2nd most polluted country, smog 15 times above safe levels
Bangladesh 2nd most polluted country, smog 15 times above safe levels
22 hours ago | National
Gazipur traffic gridlock as workers block highways
Gazipur traffic gridlock as workers block highways
23 hours ago | City
Healthy cheese choices for guilt-free indulgence
Healthy cheese choices for guilt-free indulgence
21 hours ago | Lifestyle
Gazipur workers end blockades on highways, traffic resumes
Gazipur workers end blockades on highways, traffic resumes
21 hours ago | City
Violence against women: Students stage protest at Shahbagh
Violence against women: Students stage protest at Shahbagh
21 hours ago | National
Instability hinders business, Eid sales expected to decline
Instability hinders business, Eid sales expected to decline
23 hours ago | Business
7th Bangladesh-Japan Joint Public Private Partnership meeting held in Tokyo
7th Bangladesh-Japan Joint Public Private Partnership meeting held in Tokyo
18 hours ago | National
Take firm action against rape within seven days: Morshed Hasan Khan
Take firm action against rape within seven days: Morshed Hasan Khan
19 hours ago | National
ACC asked to freeze 124 bank accounts related to Hasina, family
ACC asked to freeze 124 bank accounts related to Hasina, family
19 hours ago | National
Philippine’s ex-President Duterte arrested on ICC warrant for killings
Philippine’s ex-President Duterte arrested on ICC warrant for killings
23 hours ago | International
Mosharraf Karim’s ‘Chakkor 302’ to release this Eid
Mosharraf Karim’s ‘Chakkor 302’ to release this Eid
22 hours ago | Entertainment
Turn naked carbs into balanced, nutritious meals
Turn naked carbs into balanced, nutritious meals
22 hours ago | Lifestyle
Minimum Fitra set at Tk 110, maximum at Tk 2,805
Minimum Fitra set at Tk 110, maximum at Tk 2,805
20 hours ago | National
Army denounces false coup allegations by Indian media
Army denounces false coup allegations by Indian media
2 hours ago | National
How to save Dhaka amid unplanned, risky industrialization
How to save Dhaka amid unplanned, risky industrialization
21 hours ago | City
Court orders seizure of 54 kathas of Summit Group land
Court orders seizure of 54 kathas of Summit Group land
1 hour ago | National
Farzana Rupa to be interrogated by taskforce over Sagar-Runi murder
Farzana Rupa to be interrogated by taskforce over Sagar-Runi murder
17 hours ago | National
Doctors at Sylhet’s Osmani Medical College on ‘Complete Shutdown’
Doctors at Sylhet’s Osmani Medical College on ‘Complete Shutdown’
23 hours ago | National
From 7.24% to 11.89%: Businesses alarmed by sharp rise in loan rates
From 7.24% to 11.89%: Businesses alarmed by sharp rise in loan rates
2 hours ago | Business
Bashundhara Shuvosangho’s Iftar programme at JU
Bashundhara Shuvosangho’s Iftar programme at JU
22 hours ago | Shuvosangho
Nearly 1,000 Civilian Deaths Over Three Years
Nearly 1,000 Civilian Deaths Over Three Years
12 hours ago | International
BGMEA leaders pledge $50 billion garment export target
BGMEA leaders pledge $50 billion garment export target
23 hours ago | Business
Travel ban imposed on Hasina, her members
Travel ban imposed on Hasina, her members
18 hours ago | National
US stock market loses $4tn as Trump presses on with tariffs
US stock market loses $4tn as Trump presses on with tariffs
23 hours ago | Business
Japan's trade minister lobbies for US tariff exemption
Japan's trade minister lobbies for US tariff exemption
19 hours ago | Business
Court freezes AKM Bahauddin’s bank accounts, attaches 2 flats
Court freezes AKM Bahauddin’s bank accounts, attaches 2 flats
17 hours ago | National
Nepal invites Bangladesh to attend 'Sagarmatha Sambaad'
Nepal invites Bangladesh to attend 'Sagarmatha Sambaad'
15 hours ago | National
Osmani’s Independence Award proposal dropped over precedence issue
Osmani’s Independence Award proposal dropped over precedence issue
1 hour ago | National
Germany, UK call on Israel to resume aid, electricity to Gaza
Germany, UK call on Israel to resume aid, electricity to Gaza
22 hours ago | International
Mahfuj for making BTV time-worthy
Mahfuj for making BTV time-worthy
15 hours ago | National