Publish: 14:30, 06 Dec, 2024

Vodafone-Three merger approval blotches UK antitrust shift

Online Desk
Vodafone-Three merger approval blotches UK antitrust shift
Image: Reuters

Britain's approval of a merger between two of its four mobile networks signals a shift in regulatory priorities, with economic growth and infrastructure investment now taking precedence over keeping consumer prices low, reports Reuters. 

On Thursday, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) cleared the $19 billion deal between Vodafone and Three UK, accepting the companies' argument that a stronger network would boost competition and benefit the economy. This decision follows a controversial move 18 months ago, when the CMA blocked Microsoft's $69 billion acquisition of Activision Blizzard, citing concerns about competition in the emerging cloud gaming sector.

On that occasion, it rejected Microsoft's offer of behavioural remedies - pledges on how the combined entity would operate to maintain competition - by saying they would be difficult to monitor.

After Microsoft protested that Britain was closed for business, the increasingly isolated CMA changed tack to approve a revised deal.

On Thursday, it accepted behavioural remedies for the Vodafone-Three deal, tasking telecoms regulator Ofcom to oversee promises on pricing and investment to satisfy its competition concerns - a change in approach for the regulator.

Britain's new Prime Minister Keir Starmer told a forum of international investors in October that the CMA - which has played a bigger role in merger control since Britain left the European Union - and other regulators had to take "growth as seriously as this room does".

That message chimed with Vodafone's Chief Executive Margherita Della Valle, who put growth at the centre of her pitch when the deal was announced in June 2023.

She pressed the point on Thursday. "Good connectivity is critical to so many parts of our lives and is central to the UK's economic growth ambitions," she said.

Britain has some of the slowest mobile speeds in Europe, ranking 22nd out of 25 European countries for 5G availability and download speeds, according to analytics group OpenSignal.

Competition lawyer Alex Haffner, a partner at Fladgate, said the CMA's decision was notable for permitting a four-to-three network merger in mobile on the basis of purely behavioural remedies, reflecting a "degree of pragmatism".

"Over the past decade a multitude of four-to three mobile network mergers across Europe have been permitted only on the basis of significant structural remedies being conceded by the merging parties," he said.

Operators have long argued that those structural remedies, which often entailed the creation of new challengers, kept pricing low but constrained investment and limited the benefits of the consolidation.

CMA Chief Executive Sarah Cardell said last month the regulator must "evolve" while staying true to its mandate to promote competition for the benefit of consumers. That would include rethinking its approach to agreeing remedies.

Competition lawyer Tom Smith said the CMA's dislike of behavioural remedies seemed to become a "rigid policy position" during the Microsoft-Activision merger.

Thursday's outcome suggested that it had eased that opposition, he said, even though such remedies would still only rarely be acceptable.

"In allowing the behavioural remedies in this case, the CMA and Ofcom have consigned themselves to at least eight years of monitoring the companies' activities and debating frequent revisions to the investment plan," he said.

"It will probably be less controversial than the Activision case, but it shouldn't be."

One senior M&A adviser said there was increasingly a view that the CMA under Cardell was more open to deals that led to more growth.

Here’s a refined version of your text for clarity and impact:

"As a result, it has increasingly favored behavioral remedies over structural ones, which could lead to further consolidation in other sectors, he said. In 2019, the CMA blocked the merger between Sainsbury's and Asda—a deal that would have combined two of Britain's four largest supermarkets."

Bd-pratidin English/ Jisan

More News
Toyota to launch EV, battery unit in China by 2027
Toyota to launch EV, battery unit in China by 2027
Elon Musk's claims of harm from OpenAI are a 'stretch'
Elon Musk's claims of harm from OpenAI are a 'stretch'
Nissan calls off Honda merger talks, Nikkei says
Nissan calls off Honda merger talks, Nikkei says
Ban on under-16s using social media is smart thing
Ban on under-16s using social media is smart thing
Australia bans Deepseek from government devices over security risks
Australia bans Deepseek from government devices over security risks
Blue Origin mimics the moon’s gravity for NASA experiments during spaceflight
Blue Origin mimics the moon’s gravity for NASA experiments during spaceflight
Google’s holiday ad surge fails to ease AI concerns
Google’s holiday ad surge fails to ease AI concerns
US company plans 100,000 humanoid robots in 4 years
US company plans 100,000 humanoid robots in 4 years
China's Chang'e-7 mission to send "Extremely Smart" flying robot to moon to look for water
China's Chang'e-7 mission to send "Extremely Smart" flying robot to moon to look for water
Hundreds of US government websites go offline amid controversial cuts
Hundreds of US government websites go offline amid controversial cuts
OpenAI forms partnership with Kakao to develop AI products in South Korea
OpenAI forms partnership with Kakao to develop AI products in South Korea
Goldman Sachs starts process of replacing bankers with AI
Goldman Sachs starts process of replacing bankers with AI
Latest News
Dr Zahid for taking steps to prevent foul plays in capital market
Dr Zahid for taking steps to prevent foul plays in capital market
just now | Business
Ship with 50,200 MT Argentine wheat arrives at Ctg port
Ship with 50,200 MT Argentine wheat arrives at Ctg port
50 seconds ago | Business
2 reform commissions submit reports to CA
2 reform commissions submit reports to CA
7 minutes ago | National
Rizwana calls for effective action against plastic pollution, clarifies government stance on single-use plastics
Rizwana calls for effective action against plastic pollution, clarifies government stance on single-use plastics
8 minutes ago | National
Efforts underway to nab fugitive killers abroad: Home Adviser
Efforts underway to nab fugitive killers abroad: Home Adviser
19 minutes ago | National
Electricity sector faces pressure due to arrears payments
Electricity sector faces pressure due to arrears payments
29 minutes ago | Special
Nepal bans solo climbs on Everest, mountains above 8000m
Nepal bans solo climbs on Everest, mountains above 8000m
34 minutes ago | Lifestyle
Handling issues in morning boosts mental health
Handling issues in morning boosts mental health
1 hour ago | Lifestyle
Toyota to launch EV, battery unit in China by 2027
Toyota to launch EV, battery unit in China by 2027
1 hour ago | Tech
Afghan Taliban suspend women's radio station
Afghan Taliban suspend women's radio station
1 hour ago | International
Elon Musk's claims of harm from OpenAI are a 'stretch'
Elon Musk's claims of harm from OpenAI are a 'stretch'
1 hour ago | Tech
Nissan calls off Honda merger talks, Nikkei says
Nissan calls off Honda merger talks, Nikkei says
1 hour ago | Tech
Petrol pumps in Northern region shut down indefinitely in protest of eviction
Petrol pumps in Northern region shut down indefinitely in protest of eviction
1 hour ago | National
JU decides to abolish ward quota in admission test
JU decides to abolish ward quota in admission test
1 hour ago | National
Gazipur road crash kills three
Gazipur road crash kills three
1 hour ago | National
Jewish population in West Bank keeps rising
Jewish population in West Bank keeps rising
1 hour ago | International
Hashan Tillakaratne quits as women’s team head coach
Hashan Tillakaratne quits as women’s team head coach
1 hour ago | Sports
Hasina assassination attempt case: All accused acquitted
Hasina assassination attempt case: All accused acquitted
2 hours ago | National
Ban on under-16s using social media is smart thing
Ban on under-16s using social media is smart thing
2 hours ago | Tech
‘Gaza is not for sale’: Americans take to streets
‘Gaza is not for sale’: Americans take to streets
2 hours ago | International
CIA's entire staff offered buyouts to quit: WSJ report
CIA's entire staff offered buyouts to quit: WSJ report
2 hours ago | International
Australia bans Deepseek from government devices over security risks
Australia bans Deepseek from government devices over security risks
2 hours ago | Tech
Abul Hayat, Dilara Zaman, Emon and Shokh in a TVC
Abul Hayat, Dilara Zaman, Emon and Shokh in a TVC
2 hours ago | Entertainment
US Postal Service stops accepting parcels from China
US Postal Service stops accepting parcels from China
3 hours ago | International
Spanish ministers agree to cut working week to 37.5 hours
Spanish ministers agree to cut working week to 37.5 hours
3 hours ago | International
Second phase of Bishwa Ijtema concluded with Akheri Munajat
Second phase of Bishwa Ijtema concluded with Akheri Munajat
3 hours ago | National
Blue Origin mimics the moon’s gravity for NASA experiments during spaceflight
Blue Origin mimics the moon’s gravity for NASA experiments during spaceflight
3 hours ago | Tech
‘Buffy the Vampire Slayer’ reboot sequel with Sarah Michelle Gellar
‘Buffy the Vampire Slayer’ reboot sequel with Sarah Michelle Gellar
3 hours ago | Entertainment
Nirapon leaders meet Chief Adviser
Nirapon leaders meet Chief Adviser
3 hours ago | National
India struggles with making climate-friendly lifestyle choices
India struggles with making climate-friendly lifestyle choices
3 hours ago | Lifestyle
Most Read
Awami League ruined country's interests to stay in power: Ishraque
Awami League ruined country's interests to stay in power: Ishraque
16 hours ago | National
JCD to observe ‘March for Justice’ for trial of BCL
JCD to observe ‘March for Justice’ for trial of BCL
20 hours ago | National
Human brain sample holds a spoonful of plastic: Study
Human brain sample holds a spoonful of plastic: Study
23 hours ago | Lifestyle
Elon Musk's claims of harm from OpenAI are a 'stretch'
Elon Musk's claims of harm from OpenAI are a 'stretch'
1 hour ago | Tech
Second phase of Bishwa Ijtema concluded with Akheri Munajat
Second phase of Bishwa Ijtema concluded with Akheri Munajat
3 hours ago | National
Dhaka to roll out counter-based pink buses Thursday
Dhaka to roll out counter-based pink buses Thursday
4 hours ago | City
Counter-based buses to operate in Dhaka from Thursday
Counter-based buses to operate in Dhaka from Thursday
22 hours ago | City
Vertical Mastercard credit card launched for ICMAB members
Vertical Mastercard credit card launched for ICMAB members
16 hours ago | Corporate Corner
2C climate target declared impossible: Study
2C climate target declared impossible: Study
5 hours ago | International
Food inflation slips to 10.72% in Jan
Food inflation slips to 10.72% in Jan
17 hours ago | Business
Another day of ferry suspension on Manikganj routes
Another day of ferry suspension on Manikganj routes
5 hours ago | National
Bangladeshi women entrepreneurs to lead UK trade mission
Bangladeshi women entrepreneurs to lead UK trade mission
6 hours ago | Business
Dhaka tops worst air quality list globally
Dhaka tops worst air quality list globally
5 hours ago | City
Sabina Yasmin returns home
Sabina Yasmin returns home
5 hours ago | Entertainment
'11yr old girl' missing from Dhaka found in Naogaon
'11yr old girl' missing from Dhaka found in Naogaon
19 hours ago | City
Ex-BSEC Chairman Shibli Rubayat-Ul-Islam arrested
Ex-BSEC Chairman Shibli Rubayat-Ul-Islam arrested
6 hours ago | National
EC to use software for smart NID card distribution
EC to use software for smart NID card distribution
4 hours ago | National
Full reports of 6 reform commissions to be published on Feb 8: Asif Nazrul
Full reports of 6 reform commissions to be published on Feb 8: Asif Nazrul
18 hours ago | National
Young voters are the game changer
Young voters are the game changer
4 hours ago | Special
CA seeks Canada's help to recover stolen money
CA seeks Canada's help to recover stolen money
21 hours ago | National
Smartphone vision syndrome: Preventing and treating eye discomfort
Smartphone vision syndrome: Preventing and treating eye discomfort
4 hours ago | Lifestyle
Nepal bans solo climbs on Everest, mountains above 8000m
Nepal bans solo climbs on Everest, mountains above 8000m
31 minutes ago | Lifestyle
Asif Nazrul shares good news from his Saudi Arabia visit
Asif Nazrul shares good news from his Saudi Arabia visit
19 hours ago | National
Work underway to convert public library books into e-books: Farooki
Work underway to convert public library books into e-books: Farooki
19 hours ago | National
Real Madrid's woes on defence compounded by new Alaba injury
Real Madrid's woes on defence compounded by new Alaba injury
18 hours ago | Sports
Target billions of dollars
Target billions of dollars
3 hours ago | Business
‘Gaza is not for sale’: Americans take to streets
‘Gaza is not for sale’: Americans take to streets
2 hours ago | International
Five people shot in Sweden’s school
Five people shot in Sweden’s school
18 hours ago | International
US company plans 100,000 humanoid robots in 4 years
US company plans 100,000 humanoid robots in 4 years
22 hours ago | Tech
No ties with Israel without creation of Palestinian state: Saudi
No ties with Israel without creation of Palestinian state: Saudi
5 hours ago | International