Publish: 12:25, 15 Mar, 2025

Trump demands unprecedented control at Columbia, alarming scholars

Online Desk
Trump demands unprecedented control at Columbia, alarming scholars
AP Photo

The Trump administration brushed aside decades of precedent when it ordered Columbia University to oust the leadership of an academic department, a demand seen as a direct attack on academic freedom and a warning of what’s to come for other colleges facing federal scrutiny.

Federal officials told the university it must immediately place its Middle Eastern, South Asian, and African Studies Department under “academic receivership for a minimum of five years.” The demand was among several described as conditions for receiving federal funding, including $400 million already pulled over allegations of antisemitism.

Across academia, it was seen as a stunning intrusion.

“It’s an escalation of a kind that is unheard of,” said Joan Scott, a historian and member of the academic freedom committee of the American Association of University Professors. “Even during the McCarthy period in the United States, this was not done.”

President Donald Trump has been threatening to withhold federal funding from colleges that do not get in line with his agenda, from transgender athletes’ participating in women’s sports to diversity, equity and inclusion programs. On Friday, his administration announced investigations into 52 universities as part of his DEI crackdown.

But he has held particular fervor for Columbia, the Ivy League campus where a massive pro-Palestinian protest movement began with a tent encampment last spring. Officials continued to ratchet up pressure on the school Friday, with Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche saying the Justice Department is investigating whether it hid students sought by the U.S. over their roles in the demonstrations.

Trump and other officials have accused the protesters as being “pro-Hamas,” referring to the militant group that attacked Israel on Oct. 7, 2023.

The letter also demands that Columbia ban masks on campus meant to conceal the wearer’s identity “or intimidate others,” adopt a new definition of antisemitism, abolish its current process for disciplining students and deliver a plan to ”reform undergraduate admissions, international recruiting, and graduate admissions practices.”

The letter “obliterates the boundary between institutional autonomy and federal control,” said Ted Mitchell, president of the American Council on Education.

For generations, the federal government has given colleges space to manage their own affairs, within the constraints of federal law. The Supreme Court has long treated academic freedom as an extension of the First Amendment. Higher education leaders say autonomy is what sets America’s colleges apart and makes them a destination for top international scholars.

Trump has never hidden his contempt for the country’s most prestigious colleges, and he’s aggressively pressing his will. The federal government has almost never used its authority to cut off money from schools and colleges. But along with the initial action at Columbia, a Trump administration letter sent Monday to 60 colleges promised that penalty if they fail to make their campuses safer for Jewish students.

Still, few predicted the Trump administration would pursue the type of control it’s demanding at Columbia.

Putting an academic department under receivership is “beyond the authority of the federal government and would violate academic freedom and the First Amendment,” said Erwin Chemerinsky, a constitutional law scholar and dean of the Berkeley School of Law.

“It is chilling to see the government try to control universities in this way,” he said.

Academic receivership is a rarely used practice that puts an academic department under the oversight of a professor or administrator outside the department. It’s sometimes used to reset a department in financial or political turmoil.

The letter didn’t specify who should take control of the department at Columbia. Scott, of the AAUP, said the department appeared to be singled out because it was viewed as being overly critical of Israel.

“Receivership is a nice way of basically saying get rid of the department,” Scott said.

The Trump administration announced last week it was pulling $400 million in contracts from Columbia and reviewing another $5 billion in grants over complaints of antisemitism. The cuts have already affected research studies at Columbia’s medical center, which has long relied on grants from the National Institutes of Health.

U.S. government agencies said they made the cuts because of the school’s “continued inaction in the face of persistent harassment of Jewish students.” Some Jewish groups and the president’s supporters have argued the government should be free to condition funding to colleges as it does other entities.

The university said it’s reviewing the Trump administration’s letter. “We are committed at all times to advancing our mission, supporting our students, and addressing all forms of discrimination and hatred on our campus,” it said in a statement.

Meanwhile, it’s leaving college leaders across the U.S. on edge. Mitchell, of the American Council on Education, said college presidents he spoke with were aghast at the letter.

“It doesn’t matter whether they’re in red states or blue states or whether they’re religious institutions or sectarian institutions. This is not the government’s role,” he said.

The letter was condemned by some faculty members and free speech groups.

“Half of this stuff you can’t just do and the other half is insane,” said Joseph Howley, a Columbia professor of classics. “If the federal government can show up and demand a university department be shut down or restructured, then we don’t have universities in this country.”

The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression called it “a blueprint to supercharge censorship” at colleges.

“Our colleges need to protect free expression and comply with anti-discrimination laws, but important civil rights investigations cannot be resolved by ad hoc directives from the government,” said Tyler Coward, the group’s lead counsel for government affairs.

Source: AP

bd-pratidin/Rafid

More News
US deports hundreds of Venezuelans despite court order
US deports hundreds of Venezuelans despite court order
Erdogan backs Trump’s efforts to end Russia-Ukraine war
Erdogan backs Trump’s efforts to end Russia-Ukraine war
59 people killed in nightclub fire in North Macedonia
59 people killed in nightclub fire in North Macedonia
Yemen vows ‘professional and painful’ response to US strikes
Yemen vows ‘professional and painful’ response to US strikes
Cuba begins restoring power to Havana, outlying provinces
Cuba begins restoring power to Havana, outlying provinces
Iran denies again aiding Yemen's Houthi rebels
Iran denies again aiding Yemen's Houthi rebels
Protesters flood Belgrade in one of biggest anti-govt rallies
Protesters flood Belgrade in one of biggest anti-govt rallies
51 dead in North Macedonia nightclub fire
51 dead in North Macedonia nightclub fire
‘US has no authority dictating Iran’s foreign policy’
‘US has no authority dictating Iran’s foreign policy’
Malaysian civil servant arrested for accepting bribes for fake birth certificates
Malaysian civil servant arrested for accepting bribes for fake birth certificates
Children among 31 killed after US fighter jets bomb Yemen: Houthis
Children among 31 killed after US fighter jets bomb Yemen: Houthis
Millions of Cubans spend second night without electricity
Millions of Cubans spend second night without electricity
Latest News
Banned BCL leader held for derogatory remarks about Prophet (PBUH)
Banned BCL leader held for derogatory remarks about Prophet (PBUH)
1 second ago | City
Truth about sleep: Experts reveal how much rest you actually need
Truth about sleep: Experts reveal how much rest you actually need
2 minutes ago | Lifestyle
Tk7,000cr Kushtia EZ to boost export, jobs, and regional growth
Tk7,000cr Kushtia EZ to boost export, jobs, and regional growth
20 minutes ago | Business
ADB to provide $500mn loan for bank reforms
ADB to provide $500mn loan for bank reforms
21 minutes ago | Special
US deports hundreds of Venezuelans despite court order
US deports hundreds of Venezuelans despite court order
28 minutes ago | International
Councillor Ekramul’s wife threatens defamation suit against director Rafi, Prothom Alo
Councillor Ekramul’s wife threatens defamation suit against director Rafi, Prothom Alo
29 minutes ago | National
Newcastle end 56-year trophy drought
Newcastle end 56-year trophy drought
46 minutes ago | Sports
Erdogan backs Trump’s efforts to end Russia-Ukraine war
Erdogan backs Trump’s efforts to end Russia-Ukraine war
48 minutes ago | International
59 people killed in nightclub fire in North Macedonia
59 people killed in nightclub fire in North Macedonia
54 minutes ago | International
Hamza's coming home
Hamza's coming home
1 hour ago | Sports
Finance Adviser hints at corporate tax cuts in upcoming budget
Finance Adviser hints at corporate tax cuts in upcoming budget
1 hour ago | Business
Implementing prof Yunus’ philosophy to end violence against women
Implementing prof Yunus’ philosophy to end violence against women
1 hour ago | National
Foreigners to make grand appearance in Eid ‘Ityadi’ again
Foreigners to make grand appearance in Eid ‘Ityadi’ again
1 hour ago | Entertainment
Ex-Nagorik Committee leader announces new political platform
Ex-Nagorik Committee leader announces new political platform
1 hour ago | National
Report of ‘No parade on Independence Day’ is untrue: CA press wing
Report of ‘No parade on Independence Day’ is untrue: CA press wing
11 hours ago | National
CPD recommends raising tax-free income limit to Tk 4 lakh
CPD recommends raising tax-free income limit to Tk 4 lakh
11 hours ago | Business
Yemen vows ‘professional and painful’ response to US strikes
Yemen vows ‘professional and painful’ response to US strikes
12 hours ago | International
Oscar for Emergency? Kangana says America can keep their ‘silly’ award
Oscar for Emergency? Kangana says America can keep their ‘silly’ award
12 hours ago | Entertainment
Gold prices hiked by Tk2,613 per bhori
Gold prices hiked by Tk2,613 per bhori
12 hours ago | Business
Cuba begins restoring power to Havana, outlying provinces
Cuba begins restoring power to Havana, outlying provinces
12 hours ago | International
Fakhrul urges quick national election to restore stability
Fakhrul urges quick national election to restore stability
12 hours ago | National
People won’t tolerate excuse of delaying elections: Nazrul Islam
People won’t tolerate excuse of delaying elections: Nazrul Islam
12 hours ago | National
CA to hold special meeting with police tomorrow
CA to hold special meeting with police tomorrow
13 hours ago | National
Tarique promises trial for killings in 2024 uprising if BNP wins
Tarique promises trial for killings in 2024 uprising if BNP wins
13 hours ago | National
DMP urges people not to create suffering by blocking roads
DMP urges people not to create suffering by blocking roads
13 hours ago | City
Air chief leaves for USA
Air chief leaves for USA
13 hours ago | National
Travel ban imposed on Papon, his family
Travel ban imposed on Papon, his family
13 hours ago | National
Chinese solar company to invest in Bangladesh: envoy
Chinese solar company to invest in Bangladesh: envoy
14 hours ago | Business
BFIDC urged to produce eco-friendly products
BFIDC urged to produce eco-friendly products
14 hours ago | National
Court freezes 27 bank accounts of ex-MP Papon, family
Court freezes 27 bank accounts of ex-MP Papon, family
14 hours ago | National
Most Read
Train tickets for March 26 available online
Train tickets for March 26 available online
23 hours ago | National
Train commuters urged to buy Eid tickets from official app, counters
Train commuters urged to buy Eid tickets from official app, counters
19 hours ago | National
EU calls for international standard election in Bangladesh: CEC
EU calls for international standard election in Bangladesh: CEC
18 hours ago | National
What does spending a long time in space do to the human body?
What does spending a long time in space do to the human body?
21 hours ago | Lifestyle
Tarique Rahman takes responsibility for two Pabna orphans
Tarique Rahman takes responsibility for two Pabna orphans
20 hours ago | National
New Zealand romp to nine-wicket win in first Pakistan T20
New Zealand romp to nine-wicket win in first Pakistan T20
22 hours ago | Sports
UN Secretary General leaves Dhaka
UN Secretary General leaves Dhaka
22 hours ago | National
Dhaka Central University to be established with 7 colleges
Dhaka Central University to be established with 7 colleges
18 hours ago | City
Sunlight exposure offers life-changing health benefits, experts say
Sunlight exposure offers life-changing health benefits, experts say
20 hours ago | Lifestyle
BNP to introduce three secretary generals
BNP to introduce three secretary generals
22 hours ago | Special
Can aspirin help fight cancer?
Can aspirin help fight cancer?
22 hours ago | Lifestyle
10 timeless habits to reconnect and nourish your soul
10 timeless habits to reconnect and nourish your soul
21 hours ago | Lifestyle
Bangladeshi migrant flow increases on Mediterranean route to Europe
Bangladeshi migrant flow increases on Mediterranean route to Europe
23 hours ago | National
Weather Forecast: Mild heat wave sweeps across several districts
Weather Forecast: Mild heat wave sweeps across several districts
23 hours ago | National
Peanut farming sees promising prospects in Panchagarh
Peanut farming sees promising prospects in Panchagarh
21 hours ago | Business
David Warner set for Telugu film debut with cameo in ‘Robinhood’
David Warner set for Telugu film debut with cameo in ‘Robinhood’
23 hours ago | Entertainment
China’s Baidu unveils two new AI models amid rising competition
China’s Baidu unveils two new AI models amid rising competition
23 hours ago | Tech
NASA's stranded astronauts greet their replacements at space station
NASA's stranded astronauts greet their replacements at space station
22 hours ago | Tech
Five protein-rich alternatives to meat during Ramadan
Five protein-rich alternatives to meat during Ramadan
23 hours ago | Lifestyle
Blast from suspected old bomb in Syria kills 16
Blast from suspected old bomb in Syria kills 16
19 hours ago | International
Reforms to make Bangladesh one of the perfect democracies
Reforms to make Bangladesh one of the perfect democracies
22 hours ago | National
Death sentence of 20 BUET students in Abrar murder case upheld
Death sentence of 20 BUET students in Abrar murder case upheld
20 hours ago | National
Myanmar village air strike kills at least 12: Local official
Myanmar village air strike kills at least 12: Local official
21 hours ago | International
Judge temporarily blocks Trump's use of wartime powers to target Venezuelan gang members
Judge temporarily blocks Trump's use of wartime powers to target Venezuelan gang members
23 hours ago | International
Telegram's Durov allowed to leave France amid probe
Telegram's Durov allowed to leave France amid probe
21 hours ago | Tech
Iran, Bangladesh discuss ways to expand bilateral trade
Iran, Bangladesh discuss ways to expand bilateral trade
15 hours ago | Business
Virat Kohli not ready to retire
Virat Kohli not ready to retire
21 hours ago | Sports
AR Rahman hospitalised
AR Rahman hospitalised
21 hours ago | Entertainment
Millions of Cubans spend second night without electricity
Millions of Cubans spend second night without electricity
19 hours ago | International
Tarique promises trial for killings in 2024 uprising if BNP wins
Tarique promises trial for killings in 2024 uprising if BNP wins
13 hours ago | National