Publish: 14:24, 13 Nov, 2024

Origin of the moon

Scientists propose new theory denying ‘collision theory’

Online Desk
Scientists propose new theory denying ‘collision theory’
Photo - Collected

Scientists have been grappling with the mystery of moon’s origin for hundreds of years. The mystery partly solved in 1980s as experts then discovered that the lunar satellite was formed as the aftermath of an explosive impact with the Proto-planet Theia early in Earth's history.

But a recent study came up with another jaw-dropping theory on moon’s origin, denying the most popular “collision theory”.

A group of Penn State University researchers led by Professor Darren Williams said, “The Earth might have neatly nabbed the moon as it drifted by in a process called binary-exchange capture.”

According to the theory, the moon started life as one part of a “terrestrial planet” and when the pair passed within Earth’s pull, the moon was snagged into orbit while the second body was catapulted out into space.

“No one knows how the moon was formed,” said Professor Williams, adding, “For the last four decades, we have had one possibility for how it got there. Now, we have two.”

Williams and his co-author pointed out that, if the moon were formed from a ring of debris slowly condensing into a sphere, we should expect to find it orbiting above the equator. However, the moon’s orbit is actually tilted onto a totally different plane about seven degrees away from the equatorial plane.

To find an alternative explanation for why this might be the case, the researchers looked at a phenomenon called “binary-exchange capture”.

The explanation suggests that Earth might have ripped one of a pair of passing rocky bodies and made it into its satellite.

In support of this idea, Williams points to the example of Triton, Neptune’s largest moon. Current theories suggest that Triton was pulled into Neptune from the Kuiper Belt.

Just like moon, Triton orbits at a significantly tilted angle, leaning 67 degrees away from the planet's equator. According to mathematical models, it is quite plausible that the same thing could have happened to our moon.

In the paper published in The Planetary Science Journal, the researchers calculated that Earth could have captured an object between one and 10 percent of its total mass. At just 1.2 per cent of the Earth's mass, the moon falls comfortably within this range.

The only caveat is that the planetary binary would have had to have passed within just 80,000 miles (128,750km) of Earth at a speed below 6,700 miles per hour (10,800km). While that might seem incredibly fast, in the scale of the solar system that is the equivalent of a leisurely stroll.

The problem is that, even at these sedate speeds, when it first arrived; the moon's orbit would have been massively elliptical much like that of a comet around the sun.

However, the researchers also show how this orbit would have evolved under the influence of tidal forces.

As the moon races around the Earth, the tides would have slightly lagged behind its orbit, exerting a gravitational pull which would have slowly tamed its wild orbit.

Over thousands of years, that constant tug would have made the orbit more regular and circular until it settled into the close orbit it currently has.

“Today, the Earth tide is ahead of the Moon, high tide accelerates the orbit,” said Williams, adding, “It gives it a pulse, a little bit of boost. Over time, the Moon drifts a bit farther away.”

Now the moon is so far out that both the Sun and Earth pull on it; leading it to drift about 3cm further away every year.

This theory has some key advantages in that it explains why the moon’s orbit is so tilted and accounts for the presence of certain chemical isotopes found on the moon and not on Earth.

The theory would be hard to prove and rely on several “implausible events” happening at once, researchers said.

However, Professor Williams maintains that binary-exchange capture is a viable alternative to the standard collision theory and one that merits further consideration.

The researchers argue that planetary binaries may have been more common in the early solar system and could have plausibly gone on to create the moon.

“This opens a treasure trove of new questions and opportunities for further study,” the Professor furthered.  

Source: The Daily Mail

Bd-Pratidin English/ Afsar Munna

More News
How Dubai Police use AI to tackle children on 'alarming' social media posts
How Dubai Police use AI to tackle children on 'alarming' social media posts
Trump's win could shield TikTok from U.S. ban
Trump's win could shield TikTok from U.S. ban
India will allow Musk's Starlink to operate if passes security checks
India will allow Musk's Starlink to operate if passes security checks
Google Maps adds real-time AQI feature for smarter, healthier outdoors
Google Maps adds real-time AQI feature for smarter, healthier outdoors
New report suggests India’s adoption of AI technologies surpasses global average
New report suggests India’s adoption of AI technologies surpasses global average
Bitcoin tops $87,000 for a new record high
Bitcoin tops $87,000 for a new record high
Alien-like signal from 2023 decoded
Alien-like signal from 2023 decoded
Five ways science is making the world better
Five ways science is making the world better
These 6 words on Google could put you at risk of hackers
These 6 words on Google could put you at risk of hackers
Bitcoin surpasses $81,000 for first time
Bitcoin surpasses $81,000 for first time
Govt developing cyberbullying prevention framework: Nahid Islam
Govt developing cyberbullying prevention framework: Nahid Islam
Architects create marble-like building material from old cars
Architects create marble-like building material from old cars
Latest News
Tough action if case lodged only for harassment: Home adviser
Tough action if case lodged only for harassment: Home adviser

13 minutes ago | National

Chief Adviser returns home after joining COP29 in Baku
Chief Adviser returns home after joining COP29 in Baku

23 minutes ago | National

FIDE rapid rating chess begins on Friday
FIDE rapid rating chess begins on Friday

49 minutes ago | Sports

Human Rights Watch accuses Israel of war crimes in Gaza Strip
Human Rights Watch accuses Israel of war crimes in Gaza Strip

1 hour ago | International

Special committee formed to review political activities on DU campus
Special committee formed to review political activities on DU campus

1 hour ago | National

BNP's 31-point reform proposal will align with Interim Government's reform plans: Fakhrul
BNP's 31-point reform proposal will align with Interim Government's reform plans: Fakhrul

1 hour ago | National

Protesters injured in July-August movement meet advisers
Protesters injured in July-August movement meet advisers

1 hour ago | National

BNP wants introduction of bicameral parliamentary system: Tarique Rahman
BNP wants introduction of bicameral parliamentary system: Tarique Rahman

2 hours ago | National

Maxwell's power-hitting, Australia pace flatten Pakistan in T20I
Maxwell's power-hitting, Australia pace flatten Pakistan in T20I

2 hours ago | Sports

EU foreign policy chief wants Israel dialogue suspended over Gaza war
EU foreign policy chief wants Israel dialogue suspended over Gaza war

2 hours ago | International

South Africa refuses aid for thousands of illegal miners trapped
South Africa refuses aid for thousands of illegal miners trapped

3 hours ago | International

JCD DU announces full committee
JCD DU announces full committee

3 hours ago | National

UN reports Israel's warfare tactics in Gaza align with genocide definition
UN reports Israel's warfare tactics in Gaza align with genocide definition

4 hours ago | International

Dhaka expresses discontent over Hasina's use of mobile phones and giving statements from India
Dhaka expresses discontent over Hasina's use of mobile phones and giving statements from India

4 hours ago | National

Bangladesh Bank issues Tk 6,585 crore liquidity guarantee to 7 banks
Bangladesh Bank issues Tk 6,585 crore liquidity guarantee to 7 banks

4 hours ago | Economy

German return to nuclear power is 'logical': IAEA chief
German return to nuclear power is 'logical': IAEA chief

4 hours ago | International

UN faces uncertainty as Trump returns to US presidency
UN faces uncertainty as Trump returns to US presidency

4 hours ago | International

Kolkata-Bound flight makes emergency landing in Raipur following bomb threat
Kolkata-Bound flight makes emergency landing in Raipur following bomb threat

4 hours ago | International

Ex-MP Ali Azam Mukul sent to jail in Nahidul murder case
Ex-MP Ali Azam Mukul sent to jail in Nahidul murder case

4 hours ago | National

Woman dies in Pirojpur road accident
Woman dies in Pirojpur road accident

5 hours ago | City

Mike Tyson, 58, set to return to the ring against YouTuber Jake Paul
Mike Tyson, 58, set to return to the ring against YouTuber Jake Paul

5 hours ago | Sports

‘Bangladesh can lead in circular economy with textile recycling’
‘Bangladesh can lead in circular economy with textile recycling’

5 hours ago | Economy

France coach Didier Deschamps is fed up with questions about Mbappé's absence from his team
France coach Didier Deschamps is fed up with questions about Mbappé's absence from his team

6 hours ago | Sports

2,840 farmers receive free seeds and fertilizers
2,840 farmers receive free seeds and fertilizers

6 hours ago | City

Azerbaijan expresses interest in strengthening ties with Bangladesh
Azerbaijan expresses interest in strengthening ties with Bangladesh

6 hours ago | National

CA pledges reforming labour sector
CA pledges reforming labour sector

6 hours ago | National

1 mln migrants in US rely on temporary protections that Trump could target
1 mln migrants in US rely on temporary protections that Trump could target

6 hours ago | International

IAEA chief visits Iran to ‘reach diplomatic solutions’
IAEA chief visits Iran to ‘reach diplomatic solutions’

6 hours ago | International

$1 trillion needed in climate cash for developing nations, Experts say at COP29
$1 trillion needed in climate cash for developing nations, Experts say at COP29

6 hours ago | International

Hezbollah strikes Tel Aviv with ballistic missiles
Hezbollah strikes Tel Aviv with ballistic missiles

6 hours ago | International

Most Read
Norway sees ‘great potential’ in Bangladesh
Norway sees ‘great potential’ in Bangladesh

23 hours ago | National

Mike Tyson, 58, set to return to the ring against YouTuber Jake Paul
Mike Tyson, 58, set to return to the ring against YouTuber Jake Paul

5 hours ago | Sports

1st direct cargo vessel from Karachi arrives at Ctg port
1st direct cargo vessel from Karachi arrives at Ctg port

11 hours ago | Economy

Govt under pressure
Govt under pressure

10 hours ago | Special

Labor counsellor in Geneva stand-relieved
Labor counsellor in Geneva stand-relieved

9 hours ago | National

Three BTS members featured on Billboard's latest list
Three BTS members featured on Billboard's latest list

8 hours ago | Showbiz

High court dismisses six cases against Annie
High court dismisses six cases against Annie

7 hours ago | National

Elections will follow reforms, Prof Yunus tells AFP
Elections will follow reforms, Prof Yunus tells AFP

9 hours ago | National

Dhaka's air quality remains unhealthy
Dhaka's air quality remains unhealthy

11 hours ago | City

Two sections of quick rental law unconstitutional: HC
Two sections of quick rental law unconstitutional: HC

7 hours ago | National

Sri Lanka takes series lead with dominant victory
Sri Lanka takes series lead with dominant victory

9 hours ago | Sports

Israel killed 20 aid workers in Gaza in past month
Israel killed 20 aid workers in Gaza in past month

8 hours ago | International

Ex-lawmaker Ali Azam Mukul arrested in Hazaribagh
Ex-lawmaker Ali Azam Mukul arrested in Hazaribagh

12 hours ago | City

Former MP Solaiman Selim arrested
Former MP Solaiman Selim arrested

10 hours ago | National

Coast Guard arrests 2 most wanted dacoits in Maheshkhali
Coast Guard arrests 2 most wanted dacoits in Maheshkhali

8 hours ago | City

'Welcome back': Trump, Biden shake hands in White House
'Welcome back': Trump, Biden shake hands in White House

9 hours ago | International

CA meets Azerbaijan President
CA meets Azerbaijan President

7 hours ago | National

2,840 farmers receive free seeds and fertilizers
2,840 farmers receive free seeds and fertilizers

6 hours ago | City

PBI receives 3201-page long case docket
PBI receives 3201-page long case docket

7 hours ago | National

Weather to remain dry for 24 hours
Weather to remain dry for 24 hours

8 hours ago | National

BNP delegation meets US Embassy Chargé d'Affaires
BNP delegation meets US Embassy Chargé d'Affaires

8 hours ago | National

CA pledges reforming labour sector
CA pledges reforming labour sector

6 hours ago | National

5000-meter current nets seized from Halda River
5000-meter current nets seized from Halda River

11 hours ago | City

LC Margin for fertilizer imports relaxed
LC Margin for fertilizer imports relaxed

8 hours ago | Economy

Fishermen need permits to fish in the sea
Fishermen need permits to fish in the sea

10 hours ago | City

Shuvosangho commemorates Humayun Ahmed's 76th birthday
Shuvosangho commemorates Humayun Ahmed's 76th birthday

11 hours ago | Shuvosangho

Azerbaijan expresses interest in strengthening ties with Bangladesh
Azerbaijan expresses interest in strengthening ties with Bangladesh

6 hours ago | National

Israel Strikes Kill 47 More Gazans as Death Toll Surpasses 43,700
Israel Strikes Kill 47 More Gazans as Death Toll Surpasses 43,700

9 hours ago | International

3 DB officers injured in Khulna
3 DB officers injured in Khulna

7 hours ago | City

Permanent travel ban imposed on Taqsem A Khan
Permanent travel ban imposed on Taqsem A Khan

6 hours ago | National