Publish: 14:24, 13 Nov, 2024

Origin of the moon

Scientists propose new theory denying ‘collision theory’

Online Desk
Scientists propose new theory denying ‘collision theory’
Photo - Collected

Scientists have been grappling with the mystery of moon’s origin for hundreds of years. The mystery partly solved in 1980s as experts then discovered that the lunar satellite was formed as the aftermath of an explosive impact with the Proto-planet Theia early in Earth's history.

But a recent study came up with another jaw-dropping theory on moon’s origin, denying the most popular “collision theory”.

A group of Penn State University researchers led by Professor Darren Williams said, “The Earth might have neatly nabbed the moon as it drifted by in a process called binary-exchange capture.”

According to the theory, the moon started life as one part of a “terrestrial planet” and when the pair passed within Earth’s pull, the moon was snagged into orbit while the second body was catapulted out into space.

“No one knows how the moon was formed,” said Professor Williams, adding, “For the last four decades, we have had one possibility for how it got there. Now, we have two.”

Williams and his co-author pointed out that, if the moon were formed from a ring of debris slowly condensing into a sphere, we should expect to find it orbiting above the equator. However, the moon’s orbit is actually tilted onto a totally different plane about seven degrees away from the equatorial plane.

To find an alternative explanation for why this might be the case, the researchers looked at a phenomenon called “binary-exchange capture”.

The explanation suggests that Earth might have ripped one of a pair of passing rocky bodies and made it into its satellite.

In support of this idea, Williams points to the example of Triton, Neptune’s largest moon. Current theories suggest that Triton was pulled into Neptune from the Kuiper Belt.

Just like moon, Triton orbits at a significantly tilted angle, leaning 67 degrees away from the planet's equator. According to mathematical models, it is quite plausible that the same thing could have happened to our moon.

In the paper published in The Planetary Science Journal, the researchers calculated that Earth could have captured an object between one and 10 percent of its total mass. At just 1.2 per cent of the Earth's mass, the moon falls comfortably within this range.

The only caveat is that the planetary binary would have had to have passed within just 80,000 miles (128,750km) of Earth at a speed below 6,700 miles per hour (10,800km). While that might seem incredibly fast, in the scale of the solar system that is the equivalent of a leisurely stroll.

The problem is that, even at these sedate speeds, when it first arrived; the moon's orbit would have been massively elliptical much like that of a comet around the sun.

However, the researchers also show how this orbit would have evolved under the influence of tidal forces.

As the moon races around the Earth, the tides would have slightly lagged behind its orbit, exerting a gravitational pull which would have slowly tamed its wild orbit.

Over thousands of years, that constant tug would have made the orbit more regular and circular until it settled into the close orbit it currently has.

“Today, the Earth tide is ahead of the Moon, high tide accelerates the orbit,” said Williams, adding, “It gives it a pulse, a little bit of boost. Over time, the Moon drifts a bit farther away.”

Now the moon is so far out that both the Sun and Earth pull on it; leading it to drift about 3cm further away every year.

This theory has some key advantages in that it explains why the moon’s orbit is so tilted and accounts for the presence of certain chemical isotopes found on the moon and not on Earth.

The theory would be hard to prove and rely on several “implausible events” happening at once, researchers said.

However, Professor Williams maintains that binary-exchange capture is a viable alternative to the standard collision theory and one that merits further consideration.

The researchers argue that planetary binaries may have been more common in the early solar system and could have plausibly gone on to create the moon.

“This opens a treasure trove of new questions and opportunities for further study,” the Professor furthered.  

Source: The Daily Mail

Bd-Pratidin English/ Afsar Munna

More News
'Vague' net zero rules could derail climate goals, warns scientists
'Vague' net zero rules could derail climate goals, warns scientists
Australia introduces 'Landmark' bill to ban social media for children under 16
Australia introduces 'Landmark' bill to ban social media for children under 16
US regulators seek to break up Google, as part of punishment
US regulators seek to break up Google, as part of punishment
Microsoft to introduce voice cloning for teams meetings soon
Microsoft to introduce voice cloning for teams meetings soon
Point Nemo: The Spacecraft graveyard and earth's ultimate isolation
Point Nemo: The Spacecraft graveyard and earth's ultimate isolation
Nokia wins “multi-billion” dollar deal in India
Nokia wins “multi-billion” dollar deal in India
Think twice before uploading your medical data to AI chatbots
Think twice before uploading your medical data to AI chatbots
Lonely dolphin 'talks to itself,' scientists offer two theories
Lonely dolphin 'talks to itself,' scientists offer two theories
Instagram trials feature letting users reset recommendations in online safety push
Instagram trials feature letting users reset recommendations in online safety push
SpaceX fails to repeat Starship booster catch, as Trump watches on
SpaceX fails to repeat Starship booster catch, as Trump watches on
SpaceX launches India’s most advanced satellite
SpaceX launches India’s most advanced satellite
Mysterious robotic dog spotted outside Trump’s house!
Mysterious robotic dog spotted outside Trump’s house!
Latest News
Bashundhara Shuvosangho supports human chain against attack on students
Bashundhara Shuvosangho supports human chain against attack on students

13 minutes ago | Shuvosangho

Hollywood films ‘Wicked’ and ‘Red One’ set to premiere in Bangladesh
Hollywood films ‘Wicked’ and ‘Red One’ set to premiere in Bangladesh

46 minutes ago | Showbiz

Bangladesh tennis team beat Yemen
Bangladesh tennis team beat Yemen

1 hour ago | Sports

Advisor Syeda Rizwana Hasan urges for minimum and grant-based Allocation in COP29 negotiations
Advisor Syeda Rizwana Hasan urges for minimum and grant-based Allocation in COP29 negotiations

1 hour ago | National

Nations criticise vague climate finance deal at UN talks
Nations criticise vague climate finance deal at UN talks

1 hour ago | International

We’re reviewing election irregularities, plans punishment: Badiul Alam Majumder
We’re reviewing election irregularities, plans punishment: Badiul Alam Majumder

1 hour ago | National

Death toll in Gaza surpasses 44,000
Death toll in Gaza surpasses 44,000

2 hours ago | International

'Vague' net zero rules could derail climate goals, warns scientists
'Vague' net zero rules could derail climate goals, warns scientists

2 hours ago | Tech

International Criminal Court issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu and Hamas officials
International Criminal Court issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu and Hamas officials

2 hours ago | International

Dengue takes 9 lives in 24 hrs
Dengue takes 9 lives in 24 hrs

2 hours ago | National

Govt unveils treatment plan for injured in July-August movement
Govt unveils treatment plan for injured in July-August movement

3 hours ago | National

Battery rickshaw blockade suspended until Saturday
Battery rickshaw blockade suspended until Saturday

3 hours ago | National

Akbar to be banned for two NCL matches
Akbar to be banned for two NCL matches

3 hours ago | Sports

Two bodies recovered in Naogaon
Two bodies recovered in Naogaon

3 hours ago | City

Chief Adviser proud bringing Khaleda Zia to Senakunja
Chief Adviser proud bringing Khaleda Zia to Senakunja

3 hours ago | National

Opportunities created to decrease fuel oil price further: BPC chairman
Opportunities created to decrease fuel oil price further: BPC chairman

4 hours ago | Economy

I believe in free, fair, and credible election: CEC
I believe in free, fair, and credible election: CEC

4 hours ago | National

Shafik Rehman secures bail
Shafik Rehman secures bail

4 hours ago | National

Former UK Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott dies at age 86
Former UK Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott dies at age 86

4 hours ago | International

Khaleda Zia makes first public appearance at Senakunja in 12 years
Khaleda Zia makes first public appearance at Senakunja in 12 years

5 hours ago | National

Putin gifts over 70 animals to North Korean zoo following troop support for Russian army
Putin gifts over 70 animals to North Korean zoo following troop support for Russian army

5 hours ago | International

4 foreign tourists die from methanol tainted alcohol in Laos
4 foreign tourists die from methanol tainted alcohol in Laos

5 hours ago | International

Supreme Court stays ex-Addl AG Mehedi’s bail
Supreme Court stays ex-Addl AG Mehedi’s bail

5 hours ago | National

Farmers busy in harvesting paddy in Naogaon
Farmers busy in harvesting paddy in Naogaon

5 hours ago | City

Ukraine says Russia has launched an ICBM in an attack
Ukraine says Russia has launched an ICBM in an attack

5 hours ago | International

No artificial crisis be allowed in food supply chain: Bashir
No artificial crisis be allowed in food supply chain: Bashir

5 hours ago | City

Nasir Uddin appointed as new CEC, along with four others
Nasir Uddin appointed as new CEC, along with four others

6 hours ago | National

Garment workers block road in Gazipur protesting
Garment workers block road in Gazipur protesting

6 hours ago | City

Dr. Yunus advocates for a country where people hold ultimate power
Dr. Yunus advocates for a country where people hold ultimate power

6 hours ago | National

New DMP Commissioner Sazzad Ali takes charge
New DMP Commissioner Sazzad Ali takes charge

6 hours ago | City

Most Read
Armed Forces Day: Traffic restrictions in Dhaka Cantonment today
Armed Forces Day: Traffic restrictions in Dhaka Cantonment today

11 hours ago | City

Russia to provide 30,000 MT of fertilizer to Bangladesh free of charge
Russia to provide 30,000 MT of fertilizer to Bangladesh free of charge

8 hours ago | National

‘Provision of appeal against order of ICT to ensure fair trial’
‘Provision of appeal against order of ICT to ensure fair trial’

8 hours ago | National

Response to Israeli strikes on Beirut will be on ‘central Tel Aviv’: Hezbollah chief
Response to Israeli strikes on Beirut will be on ‘central Tel Aviv’: Hezbollah chief

23 hours ago | International

Jamaat Ameer returns country from UK
Jamaat Ameer returns country from UK

10 hours ago | National

Nasir Uddin appointed as new CEC, along with four others
Nasir Uddin appointed as new CEC, along with four others

6 hours ago | National

Yemeni forces seize Israeli ship in fresh operation
Yemeni forces seize Israeli ship in fresh operation

13 hours ago | International

US vetoes on Gaza ceasefire resolution
US vetoes on Gaza ceasefire resolution

11 hours ago | International

24 Bangladeshis return after 2-year jail term in India
24 Bangladeshis return after 2-year jail term in India

10 hours ago | National

Angela Merkel reveals strategies for dealing with Donald Trump in ‘Memoir’
Angela Merkel reveals strategies for dealing with Donald Trump in ‘Memoir’

9 hours ago | International

Dr. Yunus advocates for a country where people hold ultimate power
Dr. Yunus advocates for a country where people hold ultimate power

6 hours ago | National

Barrister Suman shifted to Habiganj jail
Barrister Suman shifted to Habiganj jail

7 hours ago | National

Khaleda Zia to join Armed Forces Day reception at Senakunja
Khaleda Zia to join Armed Forces Day reception at Senakunja

13 hours ago | National

Rickshaw drivers block railway line, disrupt communication with Dhaka
Rickshaw drivers block railway line, disrupt communication with Dhaka

9 hours ago | City

I believe in free, fair, and credible election: CEC
I believe in free, fair, and credible election: CEC

4 hours ago | National

Australia introduces 'Landmark' bill to ban social media for children under 16
Australia introduces 'Landmark' bill to ban social media for children under 16

9 hours ago | Tech

Armed Forces Day being observed
Armed Forces Day being observed

10 hours ago | National

VR training tool to boost surgical skills of ophthalmologists
VR training tool to boost surgical skills of ophthalmologists

10 hours ago | National

Chief Adviser proud bringing Khaleda Zia to Senakunja
Chief Adviser proud bringing Khaleda Zia to Senakunja

3 hours ago | National

US regulators seek to break up Google, as part of punishment
US regulators seek to break up Google, as part of punishment

9 hours ago | Tech

UNICEF appoints 16-year-old Gargee as new youth advocate in Bangladesh
UNICEF appoints 16-year-old Gargee as new youth advocate in Bangladesh

12 hours ago | National

Report on Bangladesh Pratidin: DNCC to repair road in front of Ziaur Rahman's plot
Report on Bangladesh Pratidin: DNCC to repair road in front of Ziaur Rahman's plot

11 hours ago | City

Duct-taped Banana sold for $6.2m in New York!
Duct-taped Banana sold for $6.2m in New York!

10 hours ago | Lifestyle

Bangladesh keen to work closely with Trump administration: CA
Bangladesh keen to work closely with Trump administration: CA

9 hours ago | National

Trump made no mention of Sheikh Hasina's leadership in interview
Trump made no mention of Sheikh Hasina's leadership in interview

9 hours ago | National

Garment workers block road in Gazipur protesting
Garment workers block road in Gazipur protesting

6 hours ago | City

Supreme Court stays ex-Addl AG Mehedi’s bail
Supreme Court stays ex-Addl AG Mehedi’s bail

5 hours ago | National

Microsoft to introduce voice cloning for teams meetings soon
Microsoft to introduce voice cloning for teams meetings soon

10 hours ago | Tech

Bangladesh ready to face West Indies in first test on Friday
Bangladesh ready to face West Indies in first test on Friday

9 hours ago | Sports

It’s one we need to tick off: Hazlewood
It’s one we need to tick off: Hazlewood

9 hours ago | Sports