Publish: 11:43, 30 Jul, 2022 Updated:

The contested legacy of Charu Majumder

‘Power grows out of the barrel of a gun’

Online Desk
‘Power grows out of the barrel of a gun’
Charu Majumdar (Collected)

“Bonduker Nol-i, Khomotar Utsa” (Political power grows out of the barrel of the gun), the slogan once scrawled on almost every other wall in this city is no longer visible.

However, the memory of Charu Majumder, the frail idealogue who made the 1920s Mao Zedong slogan popular in India and died in police custody 50 years ago this date, still haunts generations who have lived through the bloodbath that his Naxalites had ignited and the brutal, sometimes indiscriminate, reprisals that the state unleashed in retaliation.

Movies, theatre, poetry and novels made or penned in this city which was the epicentre of the `Naxal Amol’ (Naxalite age) still romanticise and celebrate the armed movement which the Ultra-Leftists who followed Majumder waged.

“His thoughts and the ideology behind the Naxalbari movement which was a peasants’ movement demanding share-cropper rights in North Bengal still remain relevant. The farmers’ movement is still alive.

“… Yes, we are now focussing on protecting constitutional democracy first as we feel that is more important today in the fight against fascism, nexus between remnant feudal and big business as also combat misrule by different shades of governments,” Abhijit Mazumdar, 62, son of the Naxalite leader and West Bengal state secretary of the Communist Party of India Marxist-Leninist (Liberation), told PTI in an interview.

Abhijit pointed out the current focus also formed part of the core of what Charu Majumder and the original CPI (ML), which was founded in 1969, stood for. The original CPI(ML) split into many factions of which the CPIML (L) is the largest besides being a recognised overground political party.

CPI(ML) of course did not believe in constitutional democracy and was carved out of the CPI(M) party when its radicals accused party leaders of revisionism by following the path of Parliamentary democracy and were expelled. These radicals met in Kolkata on Lenin’s birthdate April 22 in 1969 to form the new party.

Two North Bengal based Communist leaders Charu Majumder and Saroj Dutta led the new party. The name ‘Naxalites’ which common people gave its followers came from the agrarian revolt which Charu Majumder, popularly called CM, along with leaders like Kanu Sanyal and Jangal Santhal had led two years before the new party was founded, at a village named Naxalbari, near Siliguri in the northern part of the state.

Abhijit, a professor of English literature at a college in North Bengal, who was witness to his father being taken out of a police morgue to be hurriedly cremated at Kolkata’s Keoratala crematorium under the watchful eyes of the police and CRPF personnel, said with a wry smile: “Accusing intellectuals involved in the Bhima Koregaon movement of being ‘Urban Naxals’ itself shows the continued relevance of the movement.” However, despite winning a dozen seats in Bihar’s legislature and one in Jharkhand, the party has no representatives in the state where it was founded despite pockets of support in North Bengal and in a few border districts of the state.

Dipankar Bhattacharya, the general secretary of CPIML (L) told PTI: “We are trying to demystify Charu Majumder’s legacy. Naxalbari movement was an outcome of the earlier ‘Tebhaga’ share-croppers movement, it wasn’t air-dropped from China as some would have it.” “Yes, some mistakes were made (by the Naxal movement). The then popular slogan ‘China’s Chairman is our Chairman’ was wrong. The movement was indigenous and for the rights of farmers, tribals and students.” Charu Majumder’s CPI(ML) carried out an armed struggle against the Union which included a policy of ‘annihilation of class enemies’ hoping to bring about radical change. The only help China ever gave the movement was “moral support”.

The Indian state, alarmed more by the movement’s ideology and the popularity it gained among students and intellectuals, unleashed what many saw as a wave of extra-judicial killings to stem and end the radical uprising which came at a time when unemployment, food shortages and price rise were rampant.

Ashoke Mukhopadhyay, an author whose book ‘Charu Majumdar: The Dreamer Rebel’ is to be officially released this month and who has researched both the Naxal movement and its leader extensively, said, “Nearly 2,000 people accused of being Naxals were killed in what could be termed as extra-judicial killings between 1967 and 1972 in Bengal alone. The figure was nearly 5,000 all over India.” Many of those killed were the country’s best and brightest and included students from IIT Kharagpur, Kolkata’s prestigious Presidency and Scottish Church colleges and Jadavpur University.

“The towns of Barasat and Cossipore, certain localities in Kolkata such as Beleghata, Tollygunge and Behala besides prisons like Alipore and Dum Dum jails, virtually became killing fields,” said Mukhopadhyay, who had earlier written ‘Naxalites through the eyes of Calcutta Police’.

Many more simply went missing. Saroj Dutta, Charu Majumder’s comrade-in-arms and a former journalist with the Amrita Bazar Patrika, went missing and was found beheaded in Kolkata’s Maidan in the heart of the city in August 1971, a year before CM died.

Policemen too were killed in Naxalite ‘annihilation’ killings, some extremely brutally, bringing an edge of revenge into the battle.

Abhijit Mazumdar and many others believe that the police “killed” CM by simply denying him heart medicines and oxygen which he used to take regularly while constantly questioning him throughout his incarceration after his arrest from a Central Kolkata safehouse in the early hours of July 16, 1972.

“I came with my mother to the morgue after we learnt of his death. Our neighbours in Siliguri had bought tickets for us to fly down. What struck me as his body was shown to us was that the soles of his feet were totally black,” Abhijit said.

As the body was taken under heavy security to the cremation grounds, groups of Naxal sympathisers, emerged from the shadows to shout slogans “Comrade Charu Majumder zindabad” and then vanished into thin air as the police bore down on them.

The city remained virtually under curfew as one of India’s most influential radical Leftist ideologues and topmost Naxal leader was taken to a funeral pyre, ignoring pleas by his family for him to be taken to his hometown of Siliguri.

Home-made arms and bombs, weapons snatched from police forces, as well as abandoned Indian and Pakistani arms gathered from the battlefield of Bangladesh in the aftermath of the 1971 war were used by the young Naxalites. The legacy of that armed struggle still reflects in the political milieu of eastern and northern India where many mainstream parties patronise armed bands which work for them.

While CPIML (L) will organise memorial meetings for Majumder, who was 53 when he died, his legacy in the cities’ universities and colleges which once supported his thoughts, is today hardly to be found.

“Students have moved away from radical Left thoughts, especially so since the onset of liberalisation in 1991. Charu Majumder’s legacy, if it lives, may find more resonance among the older generation,” said Prof Sabyasachi Basu Roy Chaudhury, vice chancellor of Rabindra Bharati University.

A book, ‘Tebhaga, Naxalbari, Charu Majumder’ published by Liberation publishers for the occasion, quotes from Rabindra Nath Tagore’s poem ‘Mrityunjoy’ (One who overcame death) as the caption to CM’s last photograph taken in police custody: “No matter how great you are, You cannot be greater than death, ‘I am greater than death’ will be the words I speak, before I take my final bow.” PTI JRC NN NN

This report is auto-generated from PTI news service.

More News
Syrian insurgents seize four towns amid clashes
Syrian insurgents seize four towns amid clashes
BBC reveals list of 100 inspiring, influential women for 2024
BBC reveals list of 100 inspiring, influential women for 2024
China bans gallium, germanium exports to US over chip sanctions
China bans gallium, germanium exports to US over chip sanctions
Nigeria seeks South Africa's support to join G20, BRICS
Nigeria seeks South Africa's support to join G20, BRICS
India-China relations have progressed: S Jaishankar
India-China relations have progressed: S Jaishankar
Trump vows to hit hard Hamas if hostages are not released by Jan 20
Trump vows to hit hard Hamas if hostages are not released by Jan 20
NATO set to hold off Ukraine invite push as Trump looms
NATO set to hold off Ukraine invite push as Trump looms
Canada announces Pacific trade pact is open to new members following Taiwan's complaint
Canada announces Pacific trade pact is open to new members following Taiwan's complaint
Israel renews ban on people returning to their homes in Lebanon
Israel renews ban on people returning to their homes in Lebanon
A landmark climate change case opens at UN's highest court
A landmark climate change case opens at UN's highest court
Death toll in Thailand flooding jumps to 25
Death toll in Thailand flooding jumps to 25
Macron, Saudi Crown Prince call for a Gaza ceasefire ‘without further delay’
Macron, Saudi Crown Prince call for a Gaza ceasefire ‘without further delay’
Latest News
Bangladesh seeks global recognition of peoples’ right for water, land, food, and environment at UNCCD COP16
Bangladesh seeks global recognition of peoples’ right for water, land, food, and environment at UNCCD COP16

2 hours ago | National

Syrian insurgents seize four towns amid clashes
Syrian insurgents seize four towns amid clashes

2 hours ago | International

Chevron plans to invest in new gas exploration in Bangladesh
Chevron plans to invest in new gas exploration in Bangladesh

3 hours ago | Economy

Hindu Buddhist Christian Oikya Parishad protest attack on Agartala mission
Hindu Buddhist Christian Oikya Parishad protest attack on Agartala mission

4 hours ago | National

BBC reveals list of 100 inspiring, influential women for 2024
BBC reveals list of 100 inspiring, influential women for 2024

4 hours ago | International

Chief Adviser congratulates Bangladesh Blind Cricket Team
Chief Adviser congratulates Bangladesh Blind Cricket Team

4 hours ago | Sports

Bangladesh decides to close consular services in Agartala
Bangladesh decides to close consular services in Agartala

5 hours ago | National

CA Yunus calls for national unity
CA Yunus calls for national unity

5 hours ago | National

China bans gallium, germanium exports to US over chip sanctions
China bans gallium, germanium exports to US over chip sanctions

5 hours ago | International

India-Bangladesh ties can't be evaluated by a single issue: Pranay Verma
India-Bangladesh ties can't be evaluated by a single issue: Pranay Verma

6 hours ago | National

Messi and Ronaldo feature in shortlist for the 2024 FIFPRO Men's World XI
Messi and Ronaldo feature in shortlist for the 2024 FIFPRO Men's World XI

6 hours ago | Sports

Nigeria seeks South Africa's support to join G20, BRICS
Nigeria seeks South Africa's support to join G20, BRICS

6 hours ago | International

Jatiya Nagorik Committee presents 69-point proposal on constitution
Jatiya Nagorik Committee presents 69-point proposal on constitution

6 hours ago | National

India to lose from breakdown in ties, not Bangladesh: Adviser Shakhawat
India to lose from breakdown in ties, not Bangladesh: Adviser Shakhawat

6 hours ago | National

Bangladesh reach Jr Hockey World Cup for first time in history
Bangladesh reach Jr Hockey World Cup for first time in history

7 hours ago | Sports

Foreign Ministry summons Indian High Commissioner Pranay Verma
Foreign Ministry summons Indian High Commissioner Pranay Verma

7 hours ago | National

UN Peacekeepers are needed in India, not Bangladesh: Rizvi
UN Peacekeepers are needed in India, not Bangladesh: Rizvi

7 hours ago | National

BGB ready to tackle any untoward situation at frontiers
BGB ready to tackle any untoward situation at frontiers

7 hours ago | National

India-China relations have progressed: S Jaishankar
India-China relations have progressed: S Jaishankar

7 hours ago | International

NASA’s Sunita leads groundbreaking lettuce experiment in space
NASA’s Sunita leads groundbreaking lettuce experiment in space

8 hours ago | Tech

Apple set to launch its first foldable iPhone: A game-changer for market
Apple set to launch its first foldable iPhone: A game-changer for market

8 hours ago | Tech

Shakib undergoes test for suspected bowling action
Shakib undergoes test for suspected bowling action

8 hours ago | Sports

Fakhrul expects Indians to respect Bangladesh's democratic aspirations
Fakhrul expects Indians to respect Bangladesh's democratic aspirations

8 hours ago | National

3 cops suspended, 7 people held over Agartala incident
3 cops suspended, 7 people held over Agartala incident

8 hours ago | National

World Labs launches AI tech to generate interactive 3D scenes from a single image
World Labs launches AI tech to generate interactive 3D scenes from a single image

8 hours ago | Tech

Trump vows to hit hard Hamas if hostages are not released by Jan 20
Trump vows to hit hard Hamas if hostages are not released by Jan 20

8 hours ago | International

Intel CEO Gelsinger steps down amid struggles to regain chipmaking lead
Intel CEO Gelsinger steps down amid struggles to regain chipmaking lead

8 hours ago | Tech

NATO set to hold off Ukraine invite push as Trump looms
NATO set to hold off Ukraine invite push as Trump looms

8 hours ago | International

Did not want to give any room to the batters: Nahid Rana
Did not want to give any room to the batters: Nahid Rana

8 hours ago | Sports

Dhanmondi turns into haven for muggers
Dhanmondi turns into haven for muggers

9 hours ago | City

Most Read
Who is Rikta Akter on the BBC 100 Women 2024 list?
Who is Rikta Akter on the BBC 100 Women 2024 list?

9 hours ago | National

Diplomatic tensions rise between Bangladesh and India: Ifty Azad
Diplomatic tensions rise between Bangladesh and India: Ifty Azad

11 hours ago | National

Both elections and politics are challenges for us
Both elections and politics are challenges for us

11 hours ago | Special

BDT 2.34 trillion stashed in the pockets of bank directors
BDT 2.34 trillion stashed in the pockets of bank directors

12 hours ago | Economy

From sycophancy to burglary
From sycophancy to burglary

10 hours ago | Special

Macron, Saudi Crown Prince call for a Gaza ceasefire ‘without further delay’
Macron, Saudi Crown Prince call for a Gaza ceasefire ‘without further delay’

11 hours ago | International

Businesspeople call for security
Businesspeople call for security

12 hours ago | National

Hotels in Tripura announce no rooms, meals for Bangladeshi tourists
Hotels in Tripura announce no rooms, meals for Bangladeshi tourists

12 hours ago | National

India must understand it’s not Sheikh Hasina's Bangladesh: Asif Nazrul
India must understand it’s not Sheikh Hasina's Bangladesh: Asif Nazrul

11 hours ago | National

Rare insect fossils discovered in NZ, offering insight into ancient ecosystems
Rare insect fossils discovered in NZ, offering insight into ancient ecosystems

14 hours ago | Tech

US judge rejects Musk's $55.8 billion tesla pay deal again
US judge rejects Musk's $55.8 billion tesla pay deal again

12 hours ago | Tech

Bangladesh seeks global recognition of peoples’ right for water, land, food, and environment at UNCCD COP16
Bangladesh seeks global recognition of peoples’ right for water, land, food, and environment at UNCCD COP16

2 hours ago | National

US announces $725 million military assistance package for Ukraine
US announces $725 million military assistance package for Ukraine

14 hours ago | International

Foreign Ministry summons Indian High Commissioner Pranay Verma
Foreign Ministry summons Indian High Commissioner Pranay Verma

7 hours ago | National

Intel CEO Gelsinger steps down amid struggles to regain chipmaking lead
Intel CEO Gelsinger steps down amid struggles to regain chipmaking lead

8 hours ago | Tech

Embrace winter bliss with 5 divine World drinks hot chocolate
Embrace winter bliss with 5 divine World drinks hot chocolate

11 hours ago | Lifestyle

LPG price adjustment for Dec to be announced Tuesday
LPG price adjustment for Dec to be announced Tuesday

14 hours ago | National

Cars polluting less, but for how long?
Cars polluting less, but for how long?

10 hours ago | Tech

Govt steps in to regulate tourism on Saint Martin's Island
Govt steps in to regulate tourism on Saint Martin's Island

9 hours ago | National

Tarique urges people to show utmost restraint
Tarique urges people to show utmost restraint

9 hours ago | National

UN warns global drought carries $300 bn annual drop
UN warns global drought carries $300 bn annual drop

9 hours ago | Economy

Petition seeks ban on Indian TV channels in Bangladesh
Petition seeks ban on Indian TV channels in Bangladesh

13 hours ago | National

Tanjin Tisha hints at exciting film debut soon!
Tanjin Tisha hints at exciting film debut soon!

10 hours ago | Entertainment

Arrest warrants for Imran Khan, wife, and others over Islamabad protest
Arrest warrants for Imran Khan, wife, and others over Islamabad protest

14 hours ago | International

Canada announces Pacific trade pact is open to new members following Taiwan's complaint
Canada announces Pacific trade pact is open to new members following Taiwan's complaint

8 hours ago | International

Bangladesh’s lead crosses 200
Bangladesh’s lead crosses 200

9 hours ago | Sports

71.5% support punishing police for excessive force: Survey
71.5% support punishing police for excessive force: Survey

9 hours ago | National

Deprived deputy secretaries of 25 different cadres getting promotion soon
Deprived deputy secretaries of 25 different cadres getting promotion soon

9 hours ago | National

Shakib undergoes test for suspected bowling action
Shakib undergoes test for suspected bowling action

8 hours ago | Sports

NATO set to hold off Ukraine invite push as Trump looms
NATO set to hold off Ukraine invite push as Trump looms

8 hours ago | International