Publish: 10:02, 24 Feb, 2025 Updated: 10:10, 24 Feb, 2025

Experts warn of ethical risks as police accept donations from politicians, tycoons

Online Desk
Experts warn of ethical risks as police accept donations from politicians, tycoons
Symbolic Photo: Bd-pratidin English

The Bangladesh police force regularly receives donations—ranging from vehicles to infrastructure—from private companies, wealthy individuals, and politicians, some of whom have criminal backgrounds. While police officials justify these contributions as a necessity due to financial constraints, critics argue that they compromise law enforcement’s neutrality and create conflicts of interest.

Experts warn that relying on external donors, especially those with vested interests, undermines public trust and raises serious ethical concerns. They argue that if donors were genuinely interested in philanthropy, they could focus on sectors such as health, education, or agriculture rather than law enforcement.

Former inspector general of police (IGP) Muhammad Nurul Huda acknowledged the need for logistical support but stressed that reliance on private donations signals government inefficiency. "If the government provided adequate funding, there would be no need to accept external donations," he told the Daily Sun.

A senior police officer, speaking anonymously, explained that businesses, including banks, donate vehicles as part of corporate social responsibility or in response to police requests. While not illegal, he acknowledged that such donations foster a psychological dependence on donors.

However, Assistant Inspector General and police headquarters spokesperson Enamul Haque Sagor defended the practice, asserting that accepting logistical support does not compromise police neutrality. "The government funds police operations annually. However, it is true that some organisations voluntarily contribute patrol vehicles and traffic police boxes," he said. "There is no scope for donors to influence police duties. However, accepting support from individuals or institutions with controversial backgrounds remains a concern."

Supreme Court lawyer Monjil Morshed was more critical, equating such donations to bribery. "A state force must operate independently with government funding to maintain its integrity. When a police station accepts a Tk40-lakh vehicle from an individual, officers develop a psychological reluctance to act against them," he argued.

Police officials insist that donations are only accepted with government approval and maintain that neutrality is not compromised. "If a donor has a criminal background, we take that into account," said Dhaka Metropolitan Police (DMP) Additional Commissioner Hasan Md Shawkat Ali.

However, past cases suggest otherwise. In 2021, police in Rajbari accepted a vehicle from Zillul Hakim, an Awami League leader and former railway minister, now wanted in multiple murder cases. In 2020, Narayanganj police took a vehicle from Jatiya Party lawmaker Selim Osman, a member of a family with a history of criminal allegations. In 2023, a police camp in Cox’s Bazar received a vehicle from former Awami League MP Shaimum Sarwar Kamol, accused of land grabbing and financial crimes.

According to police data from 2024, the force had 10,946 vehicles but required at least 16,124, with a shortage of over 5,176 operational vehicles, including motorcycles. During last year’s political unrest, 1,074 police vehicles were damaged, but only 400 new ones were purchased, prompting the police to requisition private vehicles.

On 23 January 2025, Runner Group donated five motorcycles and a pickup van to the DMP. Expressing gratitude, DMP Commissioner Sheikh Md Sajjat Ali said the vehicles would enhance patrol capacity. Other private firms, such as Orix Group, have financed police infrastructure, including traffic police booths in Dhaka.

Experts warn that continued reliance on private donations could result in wealthy individuals and corporations exerting undue influence over law enforcement. "If this trend persists, the police could become a tool of the elite rather than an independent state force," lawyer Monjil Morshed cautioned.

The government, which allocates billions to various sectors, must ensure adequate funding for emergency services like the police, Morshed added. "Instead of allowing donations from individuals with vested interests, authorities should take legal action against those who use financial support to gain police protection."

Police Reform Commission Member Md Zarif Rahman noted, "We have observed that the police budget has increased only for salary and allowance, but not for logistics and other sectors. We have recommended providing police with the required number of vehicles so that they do not have to rely on wealthy and influential individuals and entities."

Repeated attempts to contact Home Adviser Lt Gen (retd) Md Jahangir Alam Chowdhury for comment on 17-18 February went unanswered.

Source: Daily Sun

Bd-pratidin English/ Jisan

More News
Yunus-Modi talks in Bangkok will benefit peoples of both countries, hopes Mirza Fakhrul
Yunus-Modi talks in Bangkok will benefit peoples of both countries, hopes Mirza Fakhrul
BNP to arrange countrywide Swadhinata Concert
BNP to arrange countrywide Swadhinata Concert
India keen in building positive, constructive relations with Bangladesh: Vikram Misri
India keen in building positive, constructive relations with Bangladesh: Vikram Misri
CA urges Thailand to ease visa procedures
CA urges Thailand to ease visa procedures
Myanmar agrees to take back 1.8 lakh Rohingyas
Myanmar agrees to take back 1.8 lakh Rohingyas
NCP ready to take challenge to contest in 300 seats: Sarjis
NCP ready to take challenge to contest in 300 seats: Sarjis
CA holds bilateral meeting with Sri Lankan premier
CA holds bilateral meeting with Sri Lankan premier
Prof. Yunus presents photograph to Modi
Prof. Yunus presents photograph to Modi
BIMSTEC secretary general meets CA
BIMSTEC secretary general meets CA
Yunus-Modi meeting fruitful: Press Secretary
Yunus-Modi meeting fruitful: Press Secretary
IMF team to arrive in Dhaka tomorrow
IMF team to arrive in Dhaka tomorrow
Extortion fuels unrest in CHT: Home Adviser
Extortion fuels unrest in CHT: Home Adviser
Latest News
China files lawsuit with WTO following US new tariffs
China files lawsuit with WTO following US new tariffs
5 hours ago | International
Yunus-Modi talks in Bangkok will benefit peoples of both countries, hopes Mirza Fakhrul
Yunus-Modi talks in Bangkok will benefit peoples of both countries, hopes Mirza Fakhrul
6 hours ago | National
China hits back at Trump tariffs with 34% tax on US goods
China hits back at Trump tariffs with 34% tax on US goods
6 hours ago | International
BNP to arrange countrywide Swadhinata Concert
BNP to arrange countrywide Swadhinata Concert
7 hours ago | National
India keen in building positive, constructive relations with Bangladesh: Vikram Misri
India keen in building positive, constructive relations with Bangladesh: Vikram Misri
7 hours ago | National
SAFF extraordinary congress held
SAFF extraordinary congress held
8 hours ago | Sports
Elton John says new album 'freshest' since 1970s
Elton John says new album 'freshest' since 1970s
8 hours ago | Entertainment
CA urges Thailand to ease visa procedures
CA urges Thailand to ease visa procedures
8 hours ago | National
Families of Duterte drug war victims demand probe into online threats
Families of Duterte drug war victims demand probe into online threats
8 hours ago | International
Sisu – the Finnish concept of action and creativity in hard times
Sisu – the Finnish concept of action and creativity in hard times
9 hours ago | Lifestyle
Myanmar agrees to take back 1.8 lakh Rohingyas
Myanmar agrees to take back 1.8 lakh Rohingyas
9 hours ago | National
China imposes 34% tariffs on US goods in retaliation for Trump’s trade war
China imposes 34% tariffs on US goods in retaliation for Trump’s trade war
9 hours ago | International
NCP ready to take challenge to contest in 300 seats: Sarjis
NCP ready to take challenge to contest in 300 seats: Sarjis
10 hours ago | National
CA holds bilateral meeting with Sri Lankan premier
CA holds bilateral meeting with Sri Lankan premier
10 hours ago | National
Security 'breakdown' allows armed men into Melbourne's MCG
Security 'breakdown' allows armed men into Melbourne's MCG
10 hours ago | Sports
Hridoy poised to succeed Tamim as Mohammedan Captain
Hridoy poised to succeed Tamim as Mohammedan Captain
10 hours ago | Sports
Pacific nations perplexed, worried by Trump tariffs
Pacific nations perplexed, worried by Trump tariffs
10 hours ago | International
Israel turns two-thirds of Gaza into no-go zones: UN
Israel turns two-thirds of Gaza into no-go zones: UN
10 hours ago | International
Mass grave of Roman-era fighters uncovered in Vienna
Mass grave of Roman-era fighters uncovered in Vienna
10 hours ago | Tech
Prof. Yunus presents photograph to Modi
Prof. Yunus presents photograph to Modi
11 hours ago | National
BIMSTEC secretary general meets CA
BIMSTEC secretary general meets CA
11 hours ago | National
Yunus-Modi meeting fruitful: Press Secretary
Yunus-Modi meeting fruitful: Press Secretary
11 hours ago | National
Europe discontent over Russia for rejecting Trump's truce push
Europe discontent over Russia for rejecting Trump's truce push
11 hours ago | International
7 killed in deadly US tornado
7 killed in deadly US tornado
11 hours ago | International
IMF team to arrive in Dhaka tomorrow
IMF team to arrive in Dhaka tomorrow
12 hours ago | National
Extortion fuels unrest in CHT: Home Adviser
Extortion fuels unrest in CHT: Home Adviser
12 hours ago | National
US tariffs a 'significant risk' to global economy: IMF
US tariffs a 'significant risk' to global economy: IMF
12 hours ago | International
CA holds bilateral talks with Bhutan PM
CA holds bilateral talks with Bhutan PM
12 hours ago | National
Trump unveils first $5 million 'gold card' visa
Trump unveils first $5 million 'gold card' visa
12 hours ago | International
Key decisions ahead for Proteas and Aussies before WTC final
Key decisions ahead for Proteas and Aussies before WTC final
13 hours ago | Sports
Most Read
Dhaka's air 'unhealthy' today
Dhaka's air 'unhealthy' today
19 hours ago | City
Hasina’s extradition, border, water issues featured in Dr Yunus-Modi first-ever talks
Hasina’s extradition, border, water issues featured in Dr Yunus-Modi first-ever talks
14 hours ago | National
Turkiye condemns Israel as greatest threat to regional peace
Turkiye condemns Israel as greatest threat to regional peace
19 hours ago | International
Country’s export sector in deep crisis amid 37% US tariff
Country’s export sector in deep crisis amid 37% US tariff
16 hours ago | Business
Myanmar agrees to take back 1.8 lakh Rohingyas
Myanmar agrees to take back 1.8 lakh Rohingyas
9 hours ago | National
Bangladesh to chair BIMSTEC for 2 years
Bangladesh to chair BIMSTEC for 2 years
17 hours ago | National
Prof. Yunus presents photograph to Modi
Prof. Yunus presents photograph to Modi
11 hours ago | National
Holding polls at earliest possible time top priority: CA
Holding polls at earliest possible time top priority: CA
18 hours ago | National
Bangladesh, Thailand sign MoU to jointly combat corruption
Bangladesh, Thailand sign MoU to jointly combat corruption
13 hours ago | National
Yunus-Modi meeting fruitful: Press Secretary
Yunus-Modi meeting fruitful: Press Secretary
11 hours ago | National
White House releases AFTP report, signaling major shift in US trade policy
White House releases AFTP report, signaling major shift in US trade policy
19 hours ago | Business
Dhaka weather to stay consistent until noon
Dhaka weather to stay consistent until noon
19 hours ago | City
CA seeks humanitarian channel in Rakhine to stop further displacement
CA seeks humanitarian channel in Rakhine to stop further displacement
16 hours ago | National
Bangladesh set for relentless cricket calendar through early 2027
Bangladesh set for relentless cricket calendar through early 2027
14 hours ago | Sports
IMF team to arrive in Dhaka tomorrow
IMF team to arrive in Dhaka tomorrow
12 hours ago | National
Deadly fire on Gaza ambulances possible Israeli 'war crimes': UN official
Deadly fire on Gaza ambulances possible Israeli 'war crimes': UN official
18 hours ago | International
Sisu – the Finnish concept of action and creativity in hard times
Sisu – the Finnish concept of action and creativity in hard times
9 hours ago | Lifestyle
Mild to moderate heat wave sweeps over many districts
Mild to moderate heat wave sweeps over many districts
14 hours ago | National
Veteran Bollywood actor Manoj Kumar dies
Veteran Bollywood actor Manoj Kumar dies
13 hours ago | Entertainment
US tariffs a 'significant risk' to global economy: IMF
US tariffs a 'significant risk' to global economy: IMF
12 hours ago | International
Europe discontent over Russia for rejecting Trump's truce push
Europe discontent over Russia for rejecting Trump's truce push
11 hours ago | International
NCP ready to take challenge to contest in 300 seats: Sarjis
NCP ready to take challenge to contest in 300 seats: Sarjis
10 hours ago | National
Israel kills at least 112 Palestinians in past 24 hours
Israel kills at least 112 Palestinians in past 24 hours
14 hours ago | International
CA seeks Thai elite’s support for ASEAN membership
CA seeks Thai elite’s support for ASEAN membership
13 hours ago | National
BIMSTEC secretary general meets CA
BIMSTEC secretary general meets CA
11 hours ago | National
Japan PM Ishiba says Trump tariffs 'national crisis'
Japan PM Ishiba says Trump tariffs 'national crisis'
15 hours ago | Business
Trump unveils first $5 million 'gold card' visa
Trump unveils first $5 million 'gold card' visa
12 hours ago | International
Mass grave of Roman-era fighters uncovered in Vienna
Mass grave of Roman-era fighters uncovered in Vienna
10 hours ago | Tech
China imposes 34% tariffs on US goods in retaliation for Trump’s trade war
China imposes 34% tariffs on US goods in retaliation for Trump’s trade war
9 hours ago | International
CA holds bilateral talks with Bhutan PM
CA holds bilateral talks with Bhutan PM
12 hours ago | National