Publish: 10:02, 24 Feb, 2025

Experts warn of ethical risks as police accept donations from politicians, tycoons

Online Desk
Experts warn of ethical risks as police accept donations from politicians, tycoons
Symbolic Photo: Bd-pratidin English

The Bangladesh police force regularly receives donations—ranging from vehicles to infrastructure—from private companies, wealthy individuals, and politicians, some of whom have criminal backgrounds. While police officials justify these contributions as a necessity due to financial constraints, critics argue that they compromise law enforcement’s neutrality and create conflicts of interest.

Experts warn that relying on external donors, especially those with vested interests, undermines public trust and raises serious ethical concerns. They argue that if donors were genuinely interested in philanthropy, they could focus on sectors such as health, education, or agriculture rather than law enforcement.

Former inspector general of police (IGP) Muhammad Nurul Huda acknowledged the need for logistical support but stressed that reliance on private donations signals government inefficiency. "If the government provided adequate funding, there would be no need to accept external donations," he told the Daily Sun.

A senior police officer, speaking anonymously, explained that businesses, including banks, donate vehicles as part of corporate social responsibility or in response to police requests. While not illegal, he acknowledged that such donations foster a psychological dependence on donors.

However, Assistant Inspector General and police headquarters spokesperson Enamul Haque Sagor defended the practice, asserting that accepting logistical support does not compromise police neutrality. "The government funds police operations annually. However, it is true that some organisations voluntarily contribute patrol vehicles and traffic police boxes," he said. "There is no scope for donors to influence police duties. However, accepting support from individuals or institutions with controversial backgrounds remains a concern."

Supreme Court lawyer Monjil Morshed was more critical, equating such donations to bribery. "A state force must operate independently with government funding to maintain its integrity. When a police station accepts a Tk40-lakh vehicle from an individual, officers develop a psychological reluctance to act against them," he argued.

Police officials insist that donations are only accepted with government approval and maintain that neutrality is not compromised. "If a donor has a criminal background, we take that into account," said Dhaka Metropolitan Police (DMP) Additional Commissioner Hasan Md Shawkat Ali.

However, past cases suggest otherwise. In 2021, police in Rajbari accepted a vehicle from Zillul Hakim, an Awami League leader and former railway minister, now wanted in multiple murder cases. In 2020, Narayanganj police took a vehicle from Jatiya Party lawmaker Selim Osman, a member of a family with a history of criminal allegations. In 2023, a police camp in Cox’s Bazar received a vehicle from former Awami League MP Shaimum Sarwar Kamol, accused of land grabbing and financial crimes.

According to police data from 2024, the force had 10,946 vehicles but required at least 16,124, with a shortage of over 5,176 operational vehicles, including motorcycles. During last year’s political unrest, 1,074 police vehicles were damaged, but only 400 new ones were purchased, prompting the police to requisition private vehicles.

On 23 January 2025, Runner Group donated five motorcycles and a pickup van to the DMP. Expressing gratitude, DMP Commissioner Sheikh Md Sajjat Ali said the vehicles would enhance patrol capacity. Other private firms, such as Orix Group, have financed police infrastructure, including traffic police booths in Dhaka.

Experts warn that continued reliance on private donations could result in wealthy individuals and corporations exerting undue influence over law enforcement. "If this trend persists, the police could become a tool of the elite rather than an independent state force," lawyer Monjil Morshed cautioned.

The government, which allocates billions to various sectors, must ensure adequate funding for emergency services like the police, Morshed added. "Instead of allowing donations from individuals with vested interests, authorities should take legal action against those who use financial support to gain police protection."

Police Reform Commission Member Md Zarif Rahman noted, "We have observed that the police budget has increased only for salary and allowance, but not for logistics and other sectors. We have recommended providing police with the required number of vehicles so that they do not have to rely on wealthy and influential individuals and entities."

Repeated attempts to contact Home Adviser Lt Gen (retd) Md Jahangir Alam Chowdhury for comment on 17-18 February went unanswered.

Source: Daily Sun

Bd-pratidin English/ Jisan

More News
July Memorial Museum to be inaugurated on Aug 5
July Memorial Museum to be inaugurated on Aug 5
HC drops writ seeking judicial commission over Sohag killing
HC drops writ seeking judicial commission over Sohag killing
CA issues message on World Youth Skills Day
CA issues message on World Youth Skills Day
World Youth Skills Day tomorrow
World Youth Skills Day tomorrow
ACC to sue ex-AL MP Hanif over graft, money laundering
ACC to sue ex-AL MP Hanif over graft, money laundering
Biman successfully completes this year's post-Hajj operation
Biman successfully completes this year's post-Hajj operation
HC issues rule on declaring Abu Sayeed, Mugdha as nat’l heroes
HC issues rule on declaring Abu Sayeed, Mugdha as nat’l heroes
Nonsense words against Tarique Rahman won't be tolerated: Zainul Abedin
Nonsense words against Tarique Rahman won't be tolerated: Zainul Abedin
‘Not carriers, but godfathers involved in drug dealings should be held’
‘Not carriers, but godfathers involved in drug dealings should be held’
Ex-DMP Commissioner, 7 other policemen indicted in Chankharpool mass killing
Ex-DMP Commissioner, 7 other policemen indicted in Chankharpool mass killing
Do not malign any person or party: Jamaat Ameer
Do not malign any person or party: Jamaat Ameer
Amir Khosru criticises govt’s capital market role, pledges reforms
Amir Khosru criticises govt’s capital market role, pledges reforms
Latest News
July Memorial Museum to be inaugurated on Aug 5
July Memorial Museum to be inaugurated on Aug 5
just now | National
HC drops writ seeking judicial commission over Sohag killing
HC drops writ seeking judicial commission over Sohag killing
13 minutes ago | National
CA issues message on World Youth Skills Day
CA issues message on World Youth Skills Day
15 minutes ago | National
Magnitude 6.7 quake hits offshore eastern Indonesia
Magnitude 6.7 quake hits offshore eastern Indonesia
36 minutes ago | International
'Superman' soars to top of North American box office
'Superman' soars to top of North American box office
43 minutes ago | Showbiz
World Youth Skills Day tomorrow
World Youth Skills Day tomorrow
52 minutes ago | National
ACC to sue ex-AL MP Hanif over graft, money laundering
ACC to sue ex-AL MP Hanif over graft, money laundering
56 minutes ago | National
US special envoy arrives in Kyiv to discuss security, sanction
US special envoy arrives in Kyiv to discuss security, sanction
56 minutes ago | International
Biman successfully completes this year's post-Hajj operation
Biman successfully completes this year's post-Hajj operation
1 hour ago | National
HC issues rule on declaring Abu Sayeed, Mugdha as nat’l heroes
HC issues rule on declaring Abu Sayeed, Mugdha as nat’l heroes
1 hour ago | National
17 private banks sign MoU to support universal pension scheme
17 private banks sign MoU to support universal pension scheme
1 hour ago | Economy
Nonsense words against Tarique Rahman won't be tolerated: Zainul Abedin
Nonsense words against Tarique Rahman won't be tolerated: Zainul Abedin
1 hour ago | National
‘Not carriers, but godfathers involved in drug dealings should be held’
‘Not carriers, but godfathers involved in drug dealings should be held’
1 hour ago | National
Ex-DMP Commissioner, 7 other policemen indicted in Chankharpool mass killing
Ex-DMP Commissioner, 7 other policemen indicted in Chankharpool mass killing
1 hour ago | National
Do not malign any person or party: Jamaat Ameer
Do not malign any person or party: Jamaat Ameer
2 hours ago | National
Pilot groups reject claims of human error in Air India accident
Pilot groups reject claims of human error in Air India accident
2 hours ago | International
Netanyahu ‘openly dictating’ US in talks with Iran: Araghchi
Netanyahu ‘openly dictating’ US in talks with Iran: Araghchi
2 hours ago | International
How Queen Victoria Became the Biggest Drug Dealer of All Time
How Queen Victoria Became the Biggest Drug Dealer of All Time
3 hours ago | International
I am singing two songs in my next comedy: Aamir
I am singing two songs in my next comedy: Aamir
3 hours ago | Showbiz
Amir Khosru criticises govt’s capital market role, pledges reforms
Amir Khosru criticises govt’s capital market role, pledges reforms
3 hours ago | National
BNP to form investigation and fact-finding committee in Mitford incident
BNP to form investigation and fact-finding committee in Mitford incident
3 hours ago | National
48 Jashore Board SSC examinees finally pass after result error fixed
48 Jashore Board SSC examinees finally pass after result error fixed
3 hours ago | National
Bitcoin tops $120,000 for the first time
Bitcoin tops $120,000 for the first time
3 hours ago | Tech
Biman resumes Sylhet-Manchester direct flights after 2 months
Biman resumes Sylhet-Manchester direct flights after 2 months
3 hours ago | National
Ignoring women's rights will hinder progress: Ali Riaz
Ignoring women's rights will hinder progress: Ali Riaz
3 hours ago | National
5-minute healthy snack recipe to curb cravings
5-minute healthy snack recipe to curb cravings
4 hours ago | Lifestyle
Gratitude to Bashundhara Group for being companion in fulfilling dreams
Gratitude to Bashundhara Group for being companion in fulfilling dreams
4 hours ago | Shuvosangho
Justice Manik, Adv Qamrul shown arrested in uprising killing case
Justice Manik, Adv Qamrul shown arrested in uprising killing case
4 hours ago | National
BNP condemns alleged political plot to assassinate character of Tarique Rahman
BNP condemns alleged political plot to assassinate character of Tarique Rahman
4 hours ago | National
Heavy rainfall, waterlogging likely in Dhaka, 2 other divisions
Heavy rainfall, waterlogging likely in Dhaka, 2 other divisions
4 hours ago | National
Most Read
Salute to courage: A tribute to human rights defenders
Salute to courage: A tribute to human rights defenders
6 hours ago | Special
BNP on high alert
BNP on high alert
7 hours ago | Special
Cautionary signal no. 3 hoisted at seaports
Cautionary signal no. 3 hoisted at seaports
5 hours ago | National
Dhaka’s air quality ‘moderate’ for rainy weather
Dhaka’s air quality ‘moderate’ for rainy weather
8 hours ago | City
BTMA warns of looming factory closures amid severe textile sector crisis
BTMA warns of looming factory closures amid severe textile sector crisis
22 hours ago | Economy
Should ChatGPT give medical advice?
Should ChatGPT give medical advice?
7 hours ago | Tech
DU metro station to close from 5pm Monday
DU metro station to close from 5pm Monday
9 hours ago | City
Father is minister, son is shadow minister
Father is minister, son is shadow minister
6 hours ago | Special
BB buys $171 million in first-ever dollar auction to stabilize taka
BB buys $171 million in first-ever dollar auction to stabilize taka
5 hours ago | Economy
World Bank VP stresses need for boosting private sector, FDI in Bangladesh
World Bank VP stresses need for boosting private sector, FDI in Bangladesh
6 hours ago | Economy
Govt launches nationwide ‘combing operation’ to curb crime wave
Govt launches nationwide ‘combing operation’ to curb crime wave
9 hours ago | National
Toxic medical waste mismanagement puts public health at risk
Toxic medical waste mismanagement puts public health at risk
9 hours ago | National
30 Bangladeshis return from Iran in third phase
30 Bangladeshis return from Iran in third phase
5 hours ago | National
Trishna Rani powers Bangladesh to dramatic win over Nepal
Trishna Rani powers Bangladesh to dramatic win over Nepal
9 hours ago | Sports
Swiss investor threatens to sue BB over ICB Islamic Bank share
Swiss investor threatens to sue BB over ICB Islamic Bank share
7 hours ago | Economy
Ignoring women's rights will hinder progress: Ali Riaz
Ignoring women's rights will hinder progress: Ali Riaz
4 hours ago | National
Concert, film screening, drone show at Shaheed Minar today
Concert, film screening, drone show at Shaheed Minar today
8 hours ago | Showbiz
Minimum ticket price set at Tk300 for Pakistan T20Is
Minimum ticket price set at Tk300 for Pakistan T20Is
23 hours ago | Sports
48 Jashore Board SSC examinees finally pass after result error fixed
48 Jashore Board SSC examinees finally pass after result error fixed
3 hours ago | National
Jamaat Ameer urges national unity, responsible speech amid social tensions
Jamaat Ameer urges national unity, responsible speech amid social tensions
22 hours ago | National
Bangladesh crush Sri Lanka by 83 runs to bounce back in T20I series
Bangladesh crush Sri Lanka by 83 runs to bounce back in T20I series
19 hours ago | Sports
One more dies of dengue in 24 hours
One more dies of dengue in 24 hours
22 hours ago | National
Dhaka-north rail link restored
Dhaka-north rail link restored
4 hours ago | National
BNP cannot be put aside so easily: Mirza Fakhrul
BNP cannot be put aside so easily: Mirza Fakhrul
22 hours ago | National
Consumer Affairs Department orders to stop marketing Miniket rice
Consumer Affairs Department orders to stop marketing Miniket rice
20 hours ago | Economy
Changes coming in appointment of returning, presiding officers: CEC
Changes coming in appointment of returning, presiding officers: CEC
6 hours ago | National
Three major cities turn into crime zones
Three major cities turn into crime zones
5 hours ago | City
Jamaat leader Taher stresses legal framework for reforms before next election
Jamaat leader Taher stresses legal framework for reforms before next election
20 hours ago | National
Bangladesh bat first in 2nd T20
Bangladesh bat first in 2nd T20
22 hours ago | Sports
Bangladesh to join Emergency Summit in Colombia over Israeli violations
Bangladesh to join Emergency Summit in Colombia over Israeli violations
9 hours ago | International