Publish: 14:34, 28 Apr, 2025

India seems to be building case for striking Pakistan: NY Times

Online Desk
India seems to be building case for striking Pakistan: NY Times
Photo - Collected

Indian prime minister Narendra Modi started talking to more than a dozen international leaders following the terrorist attack in Kashmir last week, reports the New York Times.

Officials said that diplomats from 100 missions in India’s capital have also filed into the foreign ministry for briefings.

Citing four diplomats, without naming them, the media reported that the effort is not focused on de-escalating tensions with Pakistan, which India accuses of links to the attack. Instead, New Delhi seems to be preparing a case for military action against its rival.

Without naming Pakistan, Modi in a speech on Thursday promised severe punishment and the razing of terror safe havens.

Indicating the volatility of the situation, security forces from both sides have exchanged intermittent small-arms fire across the border, Indian officials reported on Sunday. One official stated the exchanges occurred on two of the past three nights, while another said it had happened for three consecutive nights.

In Kashmir, Indian forces have also begun a sweeping clampdown, arresting hundreds, and breaking into suspects’ homes, as they continue their hunt for the perpetrators.

Earlier, India announced plans to disrupt water flow to Pakistan, ordered the expulsion of some Pakistani diplomats and visitors, while Pakistan responded by suspending participation in bilateral treaties, including one governing the cease-fire along the disputed frontier.

Anti-Muslim sentiment is rising in India, with Kashmiri students facing harassment and many returning home. Five days after the attack that killed 26 civilians, India has yet to identify a group or present strong evidence linking Pakistan, which denies involvement.

Diplomats say India cited Pakistan’s past support for terrorist groups and mentioned ongoing investigations with limited technical evidence. Analysts suggest India either needs more time to gather proof or feels little pressure to justify any future action.

A military clash between nuclear-armed India and Pakistan risks quick escalation, but India faces little global pressure to restrain itself. With its growing diplomatic and economic clout, India has become more assertive. While Iran and Saudi Arabia have reached out to both sides and the UN and EU urge restraint, major powers like the US remain focused elsewhere. Analysts say India sees international support for its pursuit of justice as a green light for stronger action.

Trump administration officials have expressed strong support for India’s fight against terrorism, though it remains unclear how involved Washington will be. Three months into his term, Trump had yet to appoint an ambassador to India, reflecting South Asia’s low priority. Even if the US or others tried to intervene, their influence would be limited, as India sees the Kashmir conflict as strictly a bilateral issue with Pakistan.

The initial response from Washington has been similar to how the first Trump administration dealt with the last major flare-up over Kashmir, in 2019, said Daniel Markey, a senior fellow at the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies.

That confrontation was spurred by an attack that killed dozens of Indian security forces. The affiliation of the attackers — a militant group called Jaish-e-Muhammad — was more clear.

At that time, the Trump White House signaled support for India. The administration increased its diplomatic pressure for restraint only after India had gotten a punch in on Pakistan, with a cross-border airstrike.

The strike’s damage was disputed. Afterward, as Pakistan moved to retaliate, it got into a dogfight and shot down an Indian jet. The pilot was taken prisoner.

To make up for that fumbled response, all signs this time indicate a desire by India to do “something spectacular,” Markey said. Pakistan has vowed to match and exceed any strike by India.

“The tit-for-tat cycle could move rapidly, and the Indians and Pakistanis have inflated assessments of their own ability to manage escalation,” Markey said.

Unlike with the 2019 terrorist attack, the claims of responsibility for last week’s slaughter have been murky, with information even on the exact number of attackers less than concrete. A little-known group calling itself the Resistance Front emerged on social media to say it was behind the massacre, according to Indian news outlets. Indian officials, in private, say the group is a proxy for Lashkar-e-Taiba, a terrorist organization based in Pakistan.

The lack of clarity may help explain why India has pointed largely to Pakistan’s past support of terrorism in Kashmir to make its case for a military reprisal now. But that approach, before India has laid out its evidence even in private diplomatic discussions, has raised some eyebrows considering the gravity of the escalation. One diplomat privately wondered: Do you want to go to war with a nuclear-armed neighbor based just on past patterns?

Shiv Shankar Menon, a former national security adviser in India, said Mr. Modi had little choice but to take military action after responding with strikes against Pakistan both in 2019 and in 2016, after another terrorist attack in Kashmir. The Indian government is under pressure to respond to a major security lapse in a troubled area that it was projecting as transformed in recent years and where it has been encouraging tourism.

But Mr. Menon said the tit-for-tat between the two adversaries was unlikely to get out of hand.

“I’m not hugely worried,” he said, “because they’re both quite happy in a state of managed hostility.”

Bd-Pratidin English/ AM

More News
North Korea launches probe into warship launch accident
North Korea launches probe into warship launch accident
Trump administration blocks Harvard from enrolling international students
Trump administration blocks Harvard from enrolling international students
Trump can stop Netanyahu’s ‘political’ war on Gaza
Trump can stop Netanyahu’s ‘political’ war on Gaza
Plane crashes into California's residential street, causing huge fire
Plane crashes into California's residential street, causing huge fire
Kremlin says no agreement yet on Vatican peace talks
Kremlin says no agreement yet on Vatican peace talks
UK net migration in 2024 fell by half to 431,000: official figures
UK net migration in 2024 fell by half to 431,000: official figures
South Korea vote: Who will run Asia's fourth largest economy?
South Korea vote: Who will run Asia's fourth largest economy?
Japan shows off futuristic 'railgun' at defence expo
Japan shows off futuristic 'railgun' at defence expo
US Issues travel warning for citizens, Bangladesh among higher-risk destinations
US Issues travel warning for citizens, Bangladesh among higher-risk destinations
‘Every child in Gaza is the enemy’
‘Every child in Gaza is the enemy’
Pakistan declares Indian diplomat persona non grata
Pakistan declares Indian diplomat persona non grata
Walmart slashes 1,500 tech jobs, sparks outrage over H1B hirings
Walmart slashes 1,500 tech jobs, sparks outrage over H1B hirings
Latest News
Self-Reliance in Sacrificial Animals: Govt urged to sustain livestock gains
Self-Reliance in Sacrificial Animals: Govt urged to sustain livestock gains
16 minutes ago | National
Handwriting and quiz competition held in Rajbari
Handwriting and quiz competition held in Rajbari
18 minutes ago | Shuvosangho
North Korea launches probe into warship launch accident
North Korea launches probe into warship launch accident
29 minutes ago | International
“Bohemian Ghora” trailer ignites buzz
“Bohemian Ghora” trailer ignites buzz
44 minutes ago | Entertainment
US stops making pennies due to high costs, low demand
US stops making pennies due to high costs, low demand
1 hour ago | Business
Light to moderate rain likely over parts of country
Light to moderate rain likely over parts of country
1 hour ago | National
Ishraque announces role as ‘people’s mayor’
Ishraque announces role as ‘people’s mayor’
2 hours ago | National
Hope for elections in December
Hope for elections in December
2 hours ago | Special
Trump's Golden Dome plan could launch new era of weapons in space
Trump's Golden Dome plan could launch new era of weapons in space
2 hours ago | Tech
Nazrul Concert rescheduled to May 31
Nazrul Concert rescheduled to May 31
2 hours ago | Entertainment
Dhaka tops air pollution list despite weekend traffic drop
Dhaka tops air pollution list despite weekend traffic drop
3 hours ago | City
Father-in-law gifts over $250 million to daughter-in-law before his death
Father-in-law gifts over $250 million to daughter-in-law before his death
3 hours ago | Lifestyle
UAE: Professors using AI? Students say they feel 'cheated'
UAE: Professors using AI? Students say they feel 'cheated'
3 hours ago | Tech
Jamaat Chief urges CA to call all-party talks
Jamaat Chief urges CA to call all-party talks
3 hours ago | National
Army chief’s address: Echo of the nation’s sentiment
Army chief’s address: Echo of the nation’s sentiment
3 hours ago | National
Trump administration blocks Harvard from enrolling international students
Trump administration blocks Harvard from enrolling international students
4 hours ago | International
FY26 budget: Wider tax coverage, steady rates proposed amid inflation pressure
FY26 budget: Wider tax coverage, steady rates proposed amid inflation pressure
4 hours ago | Business
Ruhul Alam Siddique assigned routine duties of foreign secretary
Ruhul Alam Siddique assigned routine duties of foreign secretary
4 hours ago | National
Politics heats up over polls, policy disputes
Politics heats up over polls, policy disputes
4 hours ago | National
626 persons sheltered in cantonments after July uprising on ‘humanitarian ground’
626 persons sheltered in cantonments after July uprising on ‘humanitarian ground’
4 hours ago | National
Trump can stop Netanyahu’s ‘political’ war on Gaza
Trump can stop Netanyahu’s ‘political’ war on Gaza
5 hours ago | International
ICT investigation officers can now arrest accused, suspects
ICT investigation officers can now arrest accused, suspects
5 hours ago | National
UK freezes properties owned by Salman F Rahman’s son
UK freezes properties owned by Salman F Rahman’s son
5 hours ago | Business
Railway starts selling advance tickets
Railway starts selling advance tickets
15 hours ago | National
Ordinance approved to rehabilitate July uprising hero, families
Ordinance approved to rehabilitate July uprising hero, families
15 hours ago | National
No possibility of dissolving NBR right now: Finance Ministry
No possibility of dissolving NBR right now: Finance Ministry
16 hours ago | Business
Women quota abolished in private teacher recruitment
Women quota abolished in private teacher recruitment
17 hours ago | National
Bappa Mazumder, family escape fire at Banani residence
Bappa Mazumder, family escape fire at Banani residence
17 hours ago | Entertainment
Plane crashes into California's residential street, causing huge fire
Plane crashes into California's residential street, causing huge fire
18 hours ago | International
Soumya out of Pakistan tour due to injury, Miraz named replacement
Soumya out of Pakistan tour due to injury, Miraz named replacement
18 hours ago | Sports
Most Read
NASA satellite captures world's largest iceberg breaking into thousands of pieces: What's Next?
NASA satellite captures world's largest iceberg breaking into thousands of pieces: What's Next?
22 hours ago | Tech
‘Will be difficult to cooperate with govt if election roadmap not announced’
‘Will be difficult to cooperate with govt if election roadmap not announced’
19 hours ago | National
Redesigned notes of Tk 20, 50, 1000 to be released before Eid
Redesigned notes of Tk 20, 50, 1000 to be released before Eid
19 hours ago | National
Soumya out of Pakistan tour due to injury, Miraz named replacement
Soumya out of Pakistan tour due to injury, Miraz named replacement
18 hours ago | Sports
Ex-deputy minister Shambhu sent to jail
Ex-deputy minister Shambhu sent to jail
20 hours ago | National
US Issues travel warning for citizens, Bangladesh among higher-risk destinations
US Issues travel warning for citizens, Bangladesh among higher-risk destinations
22 hours ago | International
KUET interim VC resigns amid protest
KUET interim VC resigns amid protest
20 hours ago | City
Justice Khandaker Diliruzzaman removed
Justice Khandaker Diliruzzaman removed
22 hours ago | National
Ishraque calls off protest, issues 48hr ultimatum
Ishraque calls off protest, issues 48hr ultimatum
20 hours ago | National
Discrepancies in Hasina's election affidavit: ACC ask EC to take action
Discrepancies in Hasina's election affidavit: ACC ask EC to take action
19 hours ago | National
Kamil Masters Exam 2023 form fill-up starts May 25
Kamil Masters Exam 2023 form fill-up starts May 25
19 hours ago | National
Dhaka commuters hit by morning downpour
Dhaka commuters hit by morning downpour
23 hours ago | City
Saudi donates 667mts of dates for Rohingya children in Bangladesh
Saudi donates 667mts of dates for Rohingya children in Bangladesh
21 hours ago | National
HC adjourns hearing on Zubaida’s appeal against conviction till Monday
HC adjourns hearing on Zubaida’s appeal against conviction till Monday
19 hours ago | National
UK freezes properties owned by Salman F Rahman’s son
UK freezes properties owned by Salman F Rahman’s son
5 hours ago | Business
Nazrul Concert rescheduled to May 31
Nazrul Concert rescheduled to May 31
2 hours ago | Entertainment
Jamaat Chief urges CA to call all-party talks
Jamaat Chief urges CA to call all-party talks
3 hours ago | National
ICT investigation officers can now arrest accused, suspects
ICT investigation officers can now arrest accused, suspects
5 hours ago | National
Ruhul Alam Siddique assigned routine duties of foreign secretary
Ruhul Alam Siddique assigned routine duties of foreign secretary
4 hours ago | National
Dhaka tops air pollution list despite weekend traffic drop
Dhaka tops air pollution list despite weekend traffic drop
3 hours ago | City
626 persons sheltered in cantonments after July uprising on ‘humanitarian ground’
626 persons sheltered in cantonments after July uprising on ‘humanitarian ground’
4 hours ago | National
Light to moderate rain likely over parts of country
Light to moderate rain likely over parts of country
1 hour ago | National
No possibility of dissolving NBR right now: Finance Ministry
No possibility of dissolving NBR right now: Finance Ministry
16 hours ago | Business
Railway starts selling advance tickets
Railway starts selling advance tickets
15 hours ago | National
Ishraque announces role as ‘people’s mayor’
Ishraque announces role as ‘people’s mayor’
2 hours ago | National
BNP’s Rizvi demands Adviser Khalilur’s removal
BNP’s Rizvi demands Adviser Khalilur’s removal
21 hours ago | National
Sustainable development demands genuine "harmony with nature"
Sustainable development demands genuine "harmony with nature"
20 hours ago | National
Fight to continue till news of Asif and Mahfuz’s resignation comes
Fight to continue till news of Asif and Mahfuz’s resignation comes
21 hours ago | National
Plane crashes into California's residential street, causing huge fire
Plane crashes into California's residential street, causing huge fire
18 hours ago | International
Women quota abolished in private teacher recruitment
Women quota abolished in private teacher recruitment
17 hours ago | National